Schneider to the Oilers?

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by Hockey

Bartschi and the 6th...

No way

[Caged Great]

Originally Posted by Hockey

Bartschi and the 6th...

I wouldn't give a 3rd for Schneider. I'd give Bryz a 3 year deal at 5 per before giving the nucks a damn thing.

[d_phaneuf]

Originally Posted by Erick Estrada

Would Luongo want to go back to a GM and a team that didn't want him? Seems to me like the Canucks have crossed a line of no return here but out of their own failures are trying to make a bad situation worse especially trading Schneider to a division rival.

if it's actually legit it's the right hockey move to make, I said right after the season I would trade Schnieder

Luongo + great Schnieder return is a better team than Schnieder + a poor Luongo return

the type of teams that could be interested (Philly, Winnipeg etc.) have the young top 6 forwards the Canucks desperately need

[Mango]

Originally Posted by hockey

bartschi and the 6th...

lol

[Enoch Root]

Originally Posted by diane_phaneuf

if it's actually legit it's the right hockey move to make, I said right after the season I would trade Schnieder

Luongo + great Schnieder return is a better team than Schnieder + a poor Luongo return

the type of teams that could be interested (Philly, Winnipeg etc.) have the young top 6 forwards the Canucks desperately need

Agreed, except that a lot of water has passed under the bridge. Too much? hard to say

Oh, as for Flames... no way - don't want to help the Nucks out of their jam

[kyuss275]

Originally Posted by diane_phaneuf

if it's actually legit it's the right hockey move to make, I said right after the season I would trade Schnieder

Luongo + great Schnieder return is a better team than Schnieder + a poor Luongo return

the type of teams that could be interested (Philly, Winnipeg etc.) have the young top 6 forwards the Canucks desperately need

He was not talking about it business wise, he was talking about Luongo mentally being fine staying in Vancouver.

Luongo seems like a great guy, but he knows that the managment would rather have Schnieder and same could be said about most of the fans. Not sure how he feels about being the 2nd choice?

[d_phaneuf]

oh ya it would be completely up to if they felt Luongo could play, I think with a new coach who can say ('it was AV who wanted Cory #1, I want you as my guy...") and there's never been any issues between him and his teammates

if they had to make it happen I think they could, but it does depend on that


can always tell him it's either this or we put you on waivers and Edmonton picks you up

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by diane_phaneuf

oh ya it would be completely up to if they felt Luongo could play, I think with a new coach who can say ('it was AV who wanted Cory #1, I want you as my guy...") and there's never been any issues between him and his teammates

if they had to make it happen I think they could, but it does depend on that


can always tell him it's either this or we put you on waivers and Edmonton picks you up

I don't think anyone picks him up on waivers

[d_phaneuf]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

I don't think anyone picks him up on waivers

Bob McKenzie disagrees with you

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by diane_phaneuf

Bob McKenzie disagrees with you

So does my wife, doesn't stop me from always being right

[IgiTang]

If nucks fans want to gauge their goalies worth, see the Jonathan Bernier deal.

It could be debated Schneider is worth more but an equal argument could be that his return would garner less simply because the nucks are in such a terribly tight spot with th two-headed monster, the cap drop and the win now mentality.

[IgiTang]

Originally Posted by Hockey

Bartschi and the 6th...

That would be the end of me being a Flames fan.

[Ashasx]

Why would we be in on Schneider?

[trackercowe]

Originally Posted by Ashasx

Why would we be in on Schneider?

Because we must be in on every player in some way, in order to frustrate us more before the draft tomorrow.

Although the truth of the matter is with out limited assets there are very few players that we could trade for, and even fewer players we should be interested in trading for.

[ah123]

Originally Posted by Ashasx

Why would we be in on Schneider?

To raise the price... If Calgary is offering 6th + prospect, Edmonton and others have to offer more

[puckluck2]

Originally Posted by ah123

To raise the price... If Calgary is offering 6th + prospect, Edmonton and others have to offer more

LOL Calgary is not offering the 6th pick. Let's just get that ridiculous notion out of this thread.

[CalgaryFan1988]

Originally Posted by Hockey

Bartschi and the 6th...

If that's what you think the Canucks will be getting, boy are you in for a disappointment. Look what the Leafs gave up for Bernier as comparison.

[Hockey]

Originally Posted by puckluck2

LOL Calgary is not offering the 6th pick. Let's just get that ridiculous notion out of this thread.

With Jay Feaster anything is possible.

[djsFlames]

I think someone threw out that proposal as a complete joke.

Why are people still running with it?

[Resolute 14]

Originally Posted by You Need a Thneed

No goalie is bringing that type of return this year. Why pay that price when there are goalies available with no acquisition cost?

Also, goaltending wasn't really the oilers' problem last season.

At his best, Dubnyk won't hurt the Oilers. But he's not a gamebreaker. And no goalie should get the kind of return the Canucks are expecting. But when you have a clearly impatient and novice GM in MacTavish, the Canucks do have an opportunity to rape the Oilers.

From the Flames perspective, Schneider is worth neither Baertschi nor the sixth pick. I might consider the 28th pick, but only the 28th pick.