Quote:
Originally Posted by MarchHare
I think Lucas is brilliant with "big picture" ideas and concepts but horrible with details like writing and directing. I don't think it's a coincidence that the two best films on his resume (The Empire Strikes Back and Raiders of the Lost Ark) are the ones where he came up with the basic outline for the story but then turned over the tasks of writing and directing to others.
|
I do agree with that, its funny because I believe that he hired Carrie Fisher as a script doctor for "Revenge of the Sith" and the dialogue selection were a lot stronger.
However I think Revenge of the Sith was rushed in terms of length of time. If you read the book, the turn of Anikan was a lot stronger, because the dialogue allowed the seduction to make sense.
In Revenge of the Sith they made the seduction and choices around the possible loss of love, with a little frustration about lack of contol of his destiny.
In the book while he was worried about losing his wife, it really focused around his lack of contol due to his lack of power. Palpatine basically convinced him that the Sith way was better because a Sith gains his knowledge through power while a Jedi gains his power through knowledge.
If they would have added 30 minutes to the movie, it would have been much stronger.
I love Lucas' imagination and I love the images. I remember being blown away at least two or three times a movie.
ie Phantom Menance - The invasion of Theed, the fight between Maul and the Jedi
Attack of the Clones - sheer density of things happening in the background during the arena fight, Kamino
Revenge of the Sith - opening battle, jedi murders, obi-wan versus Vader up until the high ground speech, the ending flashes
Star Wars - Opening scene, death of Obiwan
Empire Strikes back - Hoth invasion, I love you scene, the cave, the duel, I am your father
Return of the Jedi- The battle scene over Endor, Han makes prisoners dig their graves and murders them, the whole interaction between Luke, Palpatine and Vader, the final fight between Luke and Vader where Luke tips to the Dark side.