Shane Doan on Mantracker

[Mean Mr. Mustard]

How did a real bear look fake? Have you ever seen a bear that isn't in a zoo before?

[dissentowner]

Just for the record let us look at OLN's track record with shows they claimed were not staged and were proven to be.
Ghost Hunters
UFO Hunters
Destination Truth(They never find anything)
and the biggest one they tried to sell as the real deal - Operation Repo.
OLN scripts all their shows and then denies it, Mantracker is no different.

[Beerfest]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Just like Jay Bouwmeester is a #1 defenseman right? It looked like a fake bear and I was wrong and I can admit it. Your wrong about hockey stuff constantly and never admit it.

When did I say that?

Ive said Bouwmeester is not as bad as many on CP make him out to be.

Not sure where the not admitting when you're wrong thing came from either..

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Mean Mr. Mustard

How did a real bear look fake? Have you ever seen a bear that isn't in a zoo before?

Yes. I have seen mechanical bears that look real. The reason I thought that bear was fake is it really didn't look legit to me the way the fur folded near its arm when it reached in and how it reacted to being smacked. I also did not know the bear was very familiar with the guy who smacked it and there was a show based on his dealings with bears. What that has to do with Mantracker I have no clue, beerfest taking it off topic just to take a cheap shot.

[MrMastodonFarm]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Just for the record let us look at OLN's track record with shows they claimed were not staged and were proven to be.
Ghost Hunters
UFO Hunters
Destination Truth(They never find anything)
and the biggest one they tried to sell as the real deal - Operation Repo.
OLN scripts all their shows and then denies it, Mantracker is no different.

Out of all those shows, including Mantracker, Mantracker is the only show produced by OLN. OLN doesn't script any of those shows you listed above, they just bought the distribution rights for Canada from stations in the States.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Beerfest

When did I say that?

Ive said Bouwmeester is not as bad as many on CP make him out to be.

Not sure where the not admitting when you're wrong thing came from either..

And what did any of that have to do with Mantracker?

[Beerfest]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Just for the record let us look at OLN's track record with shows they claimed were not staged and were proven to be.
Ghost Hunters
UFO Hunters
Destination Truth(They never find anything)
and the biggest one they tried to sell as the real deal - Operation Repo.
OLN scripts all their shows and then denies it, Mantracker is no different.

Im not going to speak for Ghost Hunters, UFO Hunters or Operation Repo, but how is Destination Truth fake? You say the apparently never find anything..how does that equal fake?

[Beerfest]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

And what did any of that have to do with Mantracker?

You're the one that brought up Bouwmeester and me apparently never admitting im wrong..lol..

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by MrMastodonFarm

Out of all those shows, including Mantracker, Mantracker is the only show produced by OLN. OLN doesn't script any of those shows you listed above, they just bought the distribution rights for Canada from stations in the States.

Yet they only carry the scripted shows like that. So they produced their own, I still say it is all scripted despite what they claim. They are certainly not the first to make the claim on a show like this. You think it is real, okay. I am not buying it though.

[MrMastodonFarm]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I am buying it though.

Win!

[TylerSVT]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I still call B.S. So they go back and re-enact the whole thing? Sure they do.

"the earth is flat... look it is flat"

"Actually the earth is round and we follow an elliptical pattern around the sun"

"no... the earth is flat, i am looking right now and the earth is flat"

/facepalm

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Beerfest

You're the one that brought up Bouwmeester and me apparently never admitting im wrong..lol..

Are you for real? You derailed the thread with your smartass bear comment. Talk about the show or take a hike.

[TylerSVT]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Just for the record let us look at OLN's track record with shows they claimed were not staged and were proven to be.
Ghost Hunters
UFO Hunters
Destination Truth(They never find anything)
and the biggest one they tried to sell as the real deal - Operation Repo.
OLN scripts all their shows and then denies it, Mantracker is no different.

Yea shows like Departures and survivorman sure are fake....

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by TylerSVT

"the earth is flat... look it is flat"

"Actually the earth is round and we follow an elliptical pattern around the sun"

"no... the earth is flat, i am looking right now and the earth is flat"

/facepalm

That is your example? Ok, give me undisputable proof they don't script the show? Oh wait...*facepalm*

[TylerSVT]

This thread is now about Dissentower vs. logic

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by TylerSVT

Yea shows like Departures and survivorman sure are fake....

How do you know? Do you? No.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by TylerSVT

This thread is now about Dissentower vs. logic

Yes, it is totally against logic that a TV Network would script a show and then claim it was not. Why that is never ever happened before! Are you going to try again?

[Beerfest]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

That is your example? Ok, give me undisputable proof they don't script the show? Oh wait...*facepalm*

You're the one saying its fake. It should be up to you to provide the evidence that shows its fake, as of right now ive seen none.

[Dion]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Ya right. I am sure they hold the event and then afterwards get everybody together to re-enact it. You sound like one of those guys who cried wrestling was real even after the facts came out. I find it incredible that anybody buys that the show is not scripted.

I played golf with Mantracker (Terry Grant) himself last summer. I asked him a similar question as to wether it was fake. He said it wasn't.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Beerfest

You're the one saying its fake. It should be up to you to provide the evidence that shows its fake, as of right now ive seen none.

No, I said I believe it is fake. Have you seen any evidence to prove it isn't besides OLN saying it to keep ratings? Neither of us can prove it either way. I am totally entitled to come into a thread and say I don't believe something. Ripping somebody for doing so by taking a cheap shot instead of debating like others shows true character.