2023/2024 Trade Rumors and Speculation Thread

[Monahammer]

Tanev (50% retained) and markstrom to Toronto for Minten, 1st, Samsonov, more salary... could we get better?

[dieHARDflameZ]

Originally Posted by Monahammer

Tanev (50% retained) and markstrom to Toronto for Minten, 1st, Samsonov, more salary... could we get better?

What’s the appeal with Minten? From what I have seen so far, he just seems like an overhyped Leafs prospect.

[butterfly]

Originally Posted by Monahammer

Tanev (50% retained) and markstrom to Toronto for Minten, 1st, Samsonov, more salary... could we get better?

Sign me up.

I’d love a 1st for Tanev and getting out from Markstrom and actually getting Minten to do so?

[Royle9]

Originally Posted by Monahammer

Tanev (50% retained) and markstrom to Toronto for Minten, 1st, Samsonov, more salary... could we get better?

That's not even close to enough imo.
Samsonov is a cap dump
1st and Minten for both?? I feel like we could get more.

[butterfly]

Originally Posted by dieHARDflameZ

What’s the appeal with Minten? From what I have seen so far, he just seems like an overhyped Leafs prospect.

He’s a prospect, can’t ever have too many of them. Although I suspect you’re probably right about the hype.

[dieHARDflameZ]

Wrong thread.

[Sandman]

Minten is an excellent player- he was a standout in Leafs camp, and made the team. He is 6’2”, has high IQ, shoots well, fairly good skater, and does all the dirty work- good 200ft player (excellent defensively), and is highly competitive. Works hard in the greasy areas, and does well in faceoffs. He will not be a top-line player, but you win with players like him.

[dieHARDflameZ]

Wrong thread.

[Spurs]

Originally Posted by Monahammer

Tanev (50% retained) and markstrom to Toronto for Minten, 1st, Samsonov, more salary... could we get better?

I would hope so, but I’m not big on Minten so probably changes my view in the return.

[Sandman]

Not sure what’s going on with Samsonov this season, whether it’s him or the D in front of him, but there’s a good goalie there. I would take him in a minute.

[FlamesAddiction]

What are people's opinion on Siegenthaler in NJ? I noticed that he is on a long term deal that has an NMC kicking in after this season. He only makes $3.4 million a year until 2028 and is 26 years old.

I haven't watched NJ much, but would he be a good piece to get back for an extended Hanifin?

[dirk diggler]

just tell the "wizard" that Tanev is the next Hamonic and treliving can overpay for him like he did with Hamonic.

[GreenLantern2814]

Originally Posted by FlamesAddiction

What are people's opinion on Siegenthaler in NJ? I noticed that he is on a long term deal that has an NMC kicking in after this season. He only makes $3.4 million a year until 2028 and is 26 years old.

I haven't watched NJ much, but would he be a good piece to get back for an extended Hanifin?

Based on one viewing, he’s Chris Butler with a less pointy head.

[Sofa GM]

Originally Posted by butterfly

Sign me up.

I’d love a 1st for Tanev and getting out from Markstrom and actually getting Minten to do so?

Minten is highly overrated. Had a good Leaf’s camp and now people are high on him. When I have watched Minten play at the World Juniors I see a lot of Mark Jankowski.

That would be a very poor return for both Markstrom and a retained Tanev.

[Flamesfan05]

Originally Posted by Sandman

Minten is an excellent player- he was a standout in Leafs camp, and made the team. He is 6’2”, has high IQ, shoots well, fairly good skater, and does all the dirty work- good 200ft player (excellent defensively), and is highly competitive. Works hard in the greasy areas, and does well in faceoffs. He will not be a top-line player, but you win with players like him.

Sound like another Curtis Lazar

[Flamesfan05]

Originally Posted by dirk diggler

just tell the "wizard" that Tanev is the next Hamonic and treliving can overpay for him like he did with Hamonic.

The wizard knows him, probably obsess with him. He is just a little short on money now, be patient and you can rip him off his picks

[butterfly]

Originally Posted by Sofa GM

Minten is highly overrated. Had a good Leaf’s camp and now people are high on him. When I have watched Minten play at the World Juniors I see a lot of Mark Jankowski.

That would be a very poor return for both Markstrom and a retained Tanev.

For 40 games of Tanev and Markstrom at 2.5x$6M with no retention? Seems pretty good to me. What do you think would be a fair return?

[Goriders]

Not sure what you’d do with Samsonov if you brought him in. He’s atrocious.

I’d send him to the minors and bring Wolf up.

[Royle9]

Minten has definitely looked poor at the WJRs
Both he and Cowan the leafs prospects haven’t impressed at all… go figure.

I feel like he’s alright but he’s not a top tier prospect by any stretch.

Jankowski seems like a fair comparison at this point, prior to his demise of course.

[butterfly]

Originally Posted by Goriders

Not sure what you’d do with Samsonov if you brought him in. He’s atrocious.

I’d send him to the minors and bring Wolf up.

Nothing, just let his contract expire at the end of the year.