View Single Post
Old 02-14-2024, 07:59 PM   #1639
Oil Stain
Franchise Player
 
Oil Stain's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Blaster86 View Post
Oilers record vs Top 10 by p% in 2023-24: 4-9-1
Canucks record vs Top 10 by p% in 2023-24: 9-3-2

Flames actually have a better record vs these teams than the Oilers at 8-9-0. The increased games caused by the fact they see both the Canucks and Oilers.

Long story is, as a Canucks fan, I'm fine with top ten teams. More of those, please.
I guess the question we need to ask is, "Does regular season record against top ten teams have any kind of significance come playoff time?".

I just did a quick look at the finalists from last season.

Oilers went 3-1 vs Vegas in the reg season.
Panthers went 1-3 vs Toronto and 1-2 vs Carolina.
You know which teams won these series.

Vegas was 10W-14L against top ten teams during the 22/23 regular season.
Florida was 8W-19L.

Last year showed zero correlation between regular season Win % vs top ten teams and playoff success for the finalists.

There is no real smoking gun stat for predicting playoff success.
Points % and Expected Goals For % are currently the most accurate, but far from being a slam dunk.

Corsi used to be the best predictor, but has fallen off consistently since it became a main focus of conversation.

I got the data from this article:
https://chacemccallum.substack.com/p...s%20been%20xG.

I think in general its best to use the largest sample sizes possible, and breaking the regular season results into smaller segments is going to do more harm than good.
Oil Stain is offline