Quote:
Originally Posted by PepsiFree
You didn’t actually provide any examples, you asked others to provide examples but haven’t actually provided a single one that supports your position.
You also don’t seem to understand the UFA issue. Whether the Flames sign Hanifin and then trade him, or a team is allowed to talk to Hanifin’s agent and get confirmation that Hanifin would be willing to sign there at a price they’re willing to pay, both make his value equal to a player already signed to that contract (whatever it happens to be).So, “pending UFA” as a value detractor goes out the window. Doesn’t matter.
Can you provide a good example of a player like Hanifin moving and not getting back value similar to Holtz + a 1st? Because so far it looks like you’re either underrating Hanifin or overrating Holtz, and I’m genuinely curious what you’re basing this on.
|
Probably not going to be a close enough comparable to satisfy you so here’s some random examples to wet your palette.
Chychrun = Protected 1st + two 2nds
Hronek + 4th = Protected 1st + 2nd
Toews = Two 2nds
Trouba = Pionk + 1st
Sergachev + 2nd = Drouin + 6th
Dillon = 2nd + 3rd
Dillon = Two 2nds
Severson = 3rd
Manson = Helleson + 2nd
Barron + 2nd = Lehkonen
Sandin = Gustafson + 1st
Gavrikov + Korpisalo = Quick + 1st + 3rd
McDonagh = Mismash + Myers
McCabe + Lafferty + 2x5ths = Anderson + Gogolev + 1st + 2nd
Leddy + Witkowksi = Walman + Sundqvist + 2nd
Orlov = 5th
Middleton = Kakhonen + 5th
Marino = Smith + 3rd
Lundkvist = 1st + 4th
Romanov + 4th = 1st
Montour = 3rd
Graves = Maltsev + 2nd
Lauzon = 2nd
Jensen + 5th = Bowey + 2nd
Martinez = Two 2nds
Scandella = 2nd + 4th