Can't we look at this in an objective moral way? In a balance of harms view, there is much more harm caused to many more people by allowing trans-folk to participate in the current sporting categories defined by gender: you would have to add the comparative harm of disadvantaging all other athletes within that category.
It's not an elegant solution, but society is about compromises. We need independent sporting categories for people who have made the decision to transition. It's not perfect, but balance of harm here is pretty clear IMO.
|