Quote:
Originally Posted by FormerPresJamesTaylor
If the performances are good enough, why not? No one bats (sorry) an eye at Heath Ledger winning as the Joker.
Josh Brolin and RDJ in Infinity War, Hugh Jackman in Logan would have all been worthy nominations IMO. This list goes on.
|
I'll give you Ledger as he was deserving but Brolin and Jackman for those roles? Nah. Not even close. It's a very short list of superhero performances that have been oscar worthy and to be fair those movies are not written with Oscar performances in mind. A lot of the Oscar winning roles are from movies that were taylor-made with the Oscars in mind.