Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashasx
Seguin? Johansen? ROR?
|
I think I'd put him third.
Seguin
ROR
Monahan
Johansen
Kadri
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigrangy
Seguin
1 season of 67 points (albeit as a u20 player)
32 points in 46 games the season before the trade (lockout year)
Johansen
63, 71 and 26 (in 38) points the 2.5 seasons before the trade
ROR
20 (in 29, lockout year), 64, 55 the three seasons before the trade. 61,55,60 before the next trade.
Monahan
64, 82, 48 (in 70) last 3 years
Didn’t realize how poor he produced this year honestly but he’s still got the highest and most spotless track record of any of these guys
Isn’t immature and a bad fit for the team culture (seguin), and hasn’t drove drunk into a Timmie’s either (ror).
Monahan would be the most valuable asset traded in the last decade and the Flames better get that value.
|
Seguin maybe wasn't better at the time of the trade, but due to his age and draft pedigree I think the thought was he was on track to be an elite top line center.
ROR maybe doesn't have the point totals, but is seen as a better 2 way center for him.
But yeah I think it's close for sure.