Quote:
Originally Posted by New Era
I appreciate the effort from the writer, but I agree. The scale does this a disservice. A 5 point scale does not allow for the nuance or separation that would exist in rating the skill set of these guys. I'd also like to see some comparables of NHL players on that scale, so there is a better point of reference. Woukd like to know how some of these measures were arrived at as well.
|
Sorry to pile on as I too appreciate the effort, but 23 players were evaluated over a total of what, 9-10 hours of total ice time? That's about 20 minutes of viewing time per player assuming no distractions and players participating in drills/scrimmages 100% of the time. Seems like a lot of detail for such a brief viewing period.