So
Full Circle Pizza opened on 17th last month in the old Bensonhurst spot (damn that place had awful service), and I've been dragging my feet on going there.
Turns out it's ridiculously good. I'm hesitant to post about it in the pizza thread, because while it's technically a "pizza" place, it's definitely more of a foodie magnet kind of deal, with a wide gamut of off-beat pizzas, amazing seafood, and homemade desserts.
https://www.facebook.com/fullcirclepizza/
The octopus pizza is ridiculousssssss.
EDIT: Wanted to add that while it's a high-quality type place, the prices are actually really good.