Quote:
Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15
The vote that PE posted from you doesn't look like you were saying I jump on certain posters but not others. It looks like you were saying I ignored other peoples logic and wouldn't change my opinion. Then you continue on about how I was central to both the lynching of activeStick and Girly, yet I have posted how I wasn't that central to the activeStick lynch and I don't think you've ever commented on that.
|
Okay, so I think everyone agrees your role in getting Girly lycned, so I won't go over that. As for the Active vote, here is why I thought you were central to it.
Here is your vote for him:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Timbo
Unvote
Vote:activestick
Agreed turn up the heat.
|
1) Voting without much reason - I know it's Day 1, but still some sort of reasoning would help. The general reason from context is they were not active enough
2) Third vote - I often consider the third vote key as that takes the person from just suspicious for a few to a legit lynch candidate. Your vote pushed him over that threshold.
Follow up post to the vote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15
As far as I can tell this is activeStick's reaction to having the votes against him. Most people will give an excuse for their inactivity, he doesn't even really address his inactivity.
This reads to me like a very general comment to not really stand out, but to kind of deflect the attention. Followed up with more general questions to up the posting numbers.
It's almost like he saw he had 2 votes and thought "if people see my name a couple times maybe they will unvote me."
Also when have any games been ruined for the town? The town lost the last game and that was it, and I don't think the game was lost because of 'crazy analysis' from the town.
|
3) Timbo put a vote on Active after your vote, so now there was decent town support. It is at this time you form an argument against active. With everyone unsure on Day 1, now that active had four votes and you've re-enforced that active is a good target, it makes it easier for a few others to jump on board
In the final hours before the vote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15
Also what's the deal activeStick, you ask if the smuggler should reveal themselves and then leave? Could you maybe hang out and chat for a bit?
|
4) Not that you were wrong here, but this comment probably sealed it for Active.
So there are the four factors I considered when I said you were central to the Acitve lynching. The first two were pretty scummy to me, and lead to the third and four factors being more scummy than just first glance. To me, you putting on the third vote and then pressing the issue after the fourth vote made you central to the lynching.
All that being said, it was only Day 1, so this didn't pop up as a huge deal to me; someone has to take charge. But after you lead the charge clearly on Girly in Day 2, I saw that you were central in both lynchings. That starts a pattern, hence my increased suspicions. Further research showed you were attacking certain people and not others, which seemed like you had an agenda of who to go after. Roll all that up, and it seems like you are leading the town and have some sort of plan.