Quote:
Originally Posted by GettinIggyWithIt
Fair enough - your opinion. But Doughty is more of a complete player than both Subban and Karlsson. I would definitely take him over those two and probably Chara as well just based on age alone. Might be different if it was a younger Chara of course. I'll give you that it's a toss up between Keith and Doughty.
|
Ok, I will give you that Doughty may be a more complete player than Karlsson, but I think Karlsson is more valuable to his team.
However, what's your reasoning behind Doughty being a more complete Dman than Subban ? I disagree with this and if that was the case, Doughty would of beat out Subban for the Norris right ? As for Chara's age, it's not about that, it's how valuable he is to his team and what he brings. It's not about future planning, it's about the now. And from what I can tell so far this year, Doughty hasn't wowed anyone with anything so far this year as being a standout dman let alone a franchise player- its in spurts with him. He is not a franchise player the other 3 are (in the origional discussion).
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk