The complaints around Pointe Of View/Carlisle tended to revolve around warranties. Being a budget builder they tended to have a higher number of warranty issues but had a poor reputation for dealing with them.
I would argue that when a builder of that size feels they need to change their name, there is probably some validity to concerns. Note that the company said it was purely for "Refocusing" their business....(
Herald Link)
In general, here's a
CP thread to give you a flavor.
Hope that helps.