CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Oh sorry my bad.

Either way, if one is town and the other is mafia and considering this isn't a ####### game they can check their original PM and see if it says that their partner is 100% town.

If both say that their partner is 100% town, we know for a fact they have the same alignment.

Wasn't there an earlier post in the game where starseed has been outed and said something to the effect that he would not tell us who MOT2 is and that if he was killed that did not mean MOT 2 was the same alignment or am I wrong? I will try to look for it.

[squiggs96]

My flavour is delicious. Yes, I do think I'm funny.

Each night Pika thundershocks someone, allowing his/her night actions to go through any role blocks.

I was wary from the time the game started about posting characters and abilities. I posted on it multiple times how the wording said it wasn't necessarily tied, and that I said this means it could be. Chu's ability is tied to his character, so why wouldn't others. I thought it would have been smart for the mafia to try and get this all in the open, since they can use the mafia thread to disclose it to each other. Once they realized that their powers go along with their characters, why not trick/bully the town into revealing as well. Pika came under great fire from Oling and diss in this regard. I don't mind revealing now, since pretty much all is on the table.

Has there been anything to prove starseed and Puxlut are masons, or could it be they are just mafia using the mason role as cover, and they are communicating using their mafia thread, and not the mason thread? Pika's not accusing here, just wondering out loud.

I was trying to read up on masons, and can't find anything concrete if you have two masons, can one be a town and the other be mafia. The only thing I did find, is some moderators consider two masons to be the equivalent of one cop. Since Pika hasn't seen a cop reveal yet, maybe this is the case here, of which they'd have to be town.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Wasn't there an earlier post in the game where starseed has been outed and said something to the effect that he would not tell us who MOT2 is and that if he was killed that did not mean MOT 2 was the same alignment or am I wrong? I will try to look for it.

Uh, maybe? I don't recall.

I think you may be getting confused with him distancing himself from Timbo because they both had stars. He didn't want Timbo claiming MOT2

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

. Chu's ability is tied to his character, so why wouldn't others.

Of course, because when everyone found out you were pikachu our first thought was "yep pikachu definitely stops roleblocking, it's so obvious."

Who did you target night 3 Squiggs96? I don't know why this is a big deal but just holding it back is a huge reason I'm voting for you.

[starseed]

Mazrim initially told me that the twilight thread was a mason recruiter-esque ability. No idea how. We know 100% that each other are town. We explained as much during the reveal iirc.

When I joined the guardians, pux was unsure that my alignment changed, and mazrim later told her that she knows 100% that I am town aligned. Iirc it also specifically says that in the role pm.

I don't think we would be cop equivalents, as that probably has something to do with the main recruiter ability thing.

Also, did we determine who secret was? Was that Aeneas?

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Uh, maybe? I don't recall.

I think you may be getting confused with him distancing himself from Timbo because they both had stars. He didn't want Timbo claiming MOT2

Ya, I went back and they have had the mason claim since starseed admitted to being MOT1. That does not change the fact that twilight has not done anything to help the town and the focus always were on players we later learned were town or we now suspect are like GGG.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika came under great fire from Oling and diss in this regard. I don't mind revealing now, since pretty much all is on the table..

It was Delgar who first pointed out you were the last to reveal. It was Drury18 who wanted to keep you as an option ("If everyone else has said something and he hasn't, that might be an option. Keep active players around since it makes it more fun.") And it was GGG who first voted for you. All before I made any post about you.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Delgar

Character declares, in order of declaration:

GGG Little Mac
Oling_Roachinen Captain Falcon
Formulate Samus
East Coast Flame Pacman
Stazzy33 Link
Devo22 Mario
RatherDashing Wii Fit
Mrkajz44 Ganondorf
Wood Peach
GirlySports Yoshi
Timbo Game and Watch
Delgar Kirby
Bizaro86 Donkey Kong
Drury18 Palutena
Dissentower Sonic
Rathji Ness
Hmmmmcamo Zelda
Baxter Renegade Villager
Starseed King Dedede
GP_Matt Lucina
Puxlut Bowser

Undeclared: squiggs96

Originally Posted by Timbo

I am in hunt vermin mafia scum mode.


Whatcha hiding squiggs96? Feeling guilty, got something to hide do ya. Hmmm

Originally Posted by Drury18

Have we heard from Squiggs?

If everyone else has said something and he hasn't, that might be an option. Keep active players around since it makes it more fun.

Originally Posted by GGG

Well I am going to vote for squiggs96 because he hasn't revealed who he is yet and that is as good of reason as any we will come up with. It also puts me at the opposite end of the list. Also good to vote out the longest name as typing out long names gets tiring.

Little Mac takes out Squigs with with a star punch

vote squiggs96

One thing is we should stop lynching with one or two votes to go to give the dying person a chance to give any info before they are lynched. I will be advocating to lynch anyone who does not follow this process.

Originally Posted by Delgar

On the one hand, not posting would surprising if he were part of the dark because you'd think his teammates would be hounding him in the scum forum.

On the other hand, he's been too quiet and is the only non-delcarer.

I'm going to guess he's Luigi.

Time to toss out a vote.

Vote: squiggs96

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

It was a bit odd that we were all revealing and he didn't, but Mazrim has also said character names don't matter so I don't think he would have anything to hide in that regard. Like I said, just odd.



I've said this each game, but keeping inactive players around is usually a burden to the town. They don't provide information and give mafia an unnecessary way of hiding by just being silent. Without good cause I'll be sending my vote for someone inactive the first couple days. Puxlot has noted she's away though.

With that said it's first day and no information out so I'm not expecting a super ton of posts this weekend by everyone.

Originally Posted by dissentowner

The first lynch is always a tough one for sure. Hard to get a read on anything this early. I will wait a few days to see if squiggs chimes in but I am on board with starting with a player not really that active.

These are in chronological order, somehow Squiggs96 comes to the conclusion that me and Diss bullied him into revealing? Probably doesn't want to talk about all the confirmed town who were on board with everyone revealing...and the moderator of the game encouraging it.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

It was Delgar who first pointed out you were the last to reveal. It was Drury18 who wanted to keep you as an option ("If everyone else has said something and he hasn't, that might be an option. Keep active players around since it makes it more fun.") And it was GGG who first voted for you. All before I made any post about you.

I was more referencing when I said I thought abilities could be linked to characters. Whether you think it's a concern or not, I very much thought it was a mafia ploy to get others to reveal.

Pika thundershocked Aeneas on the missing night. I did this because he thanked my post about beating a dead horse. That and all the people I thought were town had used up their night action. Chu also thought it was funny to say he thundershocked Aeneas, thinking it would be like a shocker (think gross) but even wilder.

[Drury18]

Well, I'm going to vote for the person I trust the least and at this point that's GirlySports. She has always been near the top of my scum list.

I think the role reveal is not completely accurate and I believe it's incomplete. Her only "power" being to cause the town to mourn doesn't seem like a complete role. Especially that we've seen players hold multiple abilities to offset some passive ones. We aren't getting the whole truth from her and I don't think we ever have.

Vote: Girlysports

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika thundershocked Aeneas on the missing night. I did this because he thanked my post about beating a dead horse. That and all the people I thought were town had used up their night action. Chu also thought it was funny to say he thundershocked Aeneas, thinking it would be like a shocker (think gross) but even wilder.

So why didn't you just reveal this when asked? Multiple times...by multiple people....

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

That and all the people I thought were town had used up their night action. .

It was night 3. Only Drury18 and Wood had used their actions I think...

Not a very trusting individual.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

It was night 3. Only Drury18 and Wood had used their actions I think...

Not a very trusting individual.

That's exactly who I thought was town at that time. Why should I trust others? Pika doesn't trust many at this point either.

Not sure how we can prove we are masons except for one of us to die to prove it.
To confirm... it was said in my pm that I could trust SS. And re-confirmed it with Mazrim after SS became a Guardian. I was freaked out that the acceptance changed alignment.

[Timbo]

Puxlut You might have missed my earlier question but you said you had doubts to Dissentowners guilt,yet you and starseed had given him the extra vote/s?

oh yeah... I read that when I was out and never got back to answering.
It's not that I don't think he's shady, I just have feelings in my gut that there are others that rub me the wrong way more.
I'm not sure if I'm explaining it right?

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

So why didn't you just reveal this when asked? Multiple times...by multiple people....

Because you were annoying me, so I thought I'd return the favour. I figured I'd let you scroll through all of my posts and waste your time for the amount of time you wasted of mine. Basically pika's a jerk and he does things to amuse himself.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

oh yeah... I read that when I was out and never got back to answering.
It's not that I don't think he's shady, I just have feelings in my gut that there are others that rub me the wrong way more.
I'm not sure if I'm explaining it right?

No you are explaining this okay. So this change of mind happened from the last night until lately, that's cool do you care to share your suspicions?

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Because you were annoying me, so I thought I'd return the favour. I figured I'd let you scroll through all of my posts and waste your time for the amount of time you wasted of mine. Basically pika's a jerk and he does things to amuse himself.

Evil Pika! Your post makes me want to do some bold type

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Timbo

Evil Pika! Your post makes me want to do some bold type

After Bowser raped me, Pika just hasn't been in a very good mood.