Your All-Time, All-Flames, All-Star Game All-Stars

[Reggie Dunlop]

Just for fun while the Flames are on All Star Game hiatus....

Build your First and Second Teams

1981
C Kent Nilsson

1982
D Pekka Rautakallio

1983
RW Lanny McDonald

1984
RW Lanny McDonald

1985
D Al MacInnis
D Paul Reinhart

1986
D Gary Suter

1988
D Brad McCrimmon
D Al MacInnis
D Gary Suter
C Joe Nieuwendyk
G Mike Vernon

1989
D Gary Suter
RW Joe Mullen
C Joe Niewendyk
G Mike Vernon

1990
D Al MacInnis
RW Joe Mullen
C Joe Niewendyk
G Mike Vernon

1991
RW Theoren Fleury
D Al MacInnis
D Gary Suter
G Mike Vernon

1992
RW Theoren Fleury
D Al MacInnis
LW Gary Roberts

1993

LW Gary Roberts
G Mike Vernon

1994
D Al MacInnis
C Joe Niewendyk

1996
RW Theoren Fleury

1997
RW Theoren Fleury

1998
RW Theoren Fleury

1999
RW Theoren Fleury

2000
RW Valeri Bure
D Phil Housley

2001
Nobody

2002
RW Jarome Iginla

2003
RW Jarome Iginla

2004
RW Jarome Iginla

2007
G Miika Kiprusoff
D Dion Phaneuf

2008
RW Jarome Iginla
D Dion Phaneuf

2009
RW Jarome Iginla

2011
Nobody

2012
RW Jarom Iginla

2015
LW Johnny Gaudreau
D Mark Giordano

2016
LW Johnny Gaudreau

2017
LW Johnny Gaudreau

2018
LW Johnny Gaudrea
G Mike Smith

2020
D Mark Giordano
G David Rittich
F Matthew Tkachuk

Apologies for any omissions... I guess Rendevous '87 and other International matches in lieu of All Star Games could be included.

[Buff]

1st Team
Gaudreau - Nieuwendyk - Iginla
Giordano - MacInnis
Kiprusoff

2nd Team
Roberts - Nilsson - Mullen
Suter - Reinhart
Vernon

[looooob]

Originally Posted by Reggie Dunlop

Just for fun while the Flames are on All Star Game hiatus....

Build your First and Second Teams


2020
D Mark Giordano
G David Rittich
F Matthew Tkachuk

Apologies for any omissions... I guess Rendevous '87 and other International matches in lieu of All Star Games could be included.

Johnny is 2022 also, no?


of course Tkachuk and Markstrom both actual NHL season end allstars did not make mighty Team Pacific last year


that does happen from time to time, Hakan Loob was the NHL first team allstar RW in 88 but didn't make the allstar team- mind you 5 Flames were already on that team (and I think Rob Ramage may have been on it too and traded to the Flames shortly thereafter)

[Ford Prefect]

1st Team
Gaudreau - Nieuwendyk - Iginla
Giordano - MacInnis
Kiprusoff

2nd Team
Roberts - Tkachuk - Mullen
Suter - McCrimmon
Vernon

[Flamesfan05]

Gaudreau Nieuwendyk Iginla
Giordano MacInnis

Kipper

Roberts Gilmour Fleury
Suter Reinhart

Vernon

[Finger Cookin]

1st team is Matthew Phillips, at every position.

2nd team is Jakob Pelletier, at every position.

[timbit]

Originally Posted by Buff

1st Team
Gaudreau - Nieuwendyk - Iginla
Giordano - MacInnis
Kiprusoff

2nd Team
Roberts - Nilsson - Mullen
Suter - Reinhart
Vernon

Where is Fleury???

[dammage79]

Gaudreau-Niewy-Iginla
Gio-Chopper
Kipper

Roberts-Monahan-Fleury
Regher-Suter
Vernon (for lack of better options)

[Rejean31]

Originally Posted by dammage79

Gaudreau-Niewy-Iginla
Gio-Chopper
Kipper

Roberts-Monahan-Fleury
Regher-Suter
Vernon (for lack of better options)

Yeah, because all he did was get us over the hump against the Oilers and win us a Stanley Cup!! For lack of better options? Really???

[FireGilbert]

For a 3-on-3 all star game:

1st line: Iginla, Niewendyk, MacInnis

2nd line: Gaudreau, Fleury, Giordano

Goalies: Kipper and Vernon.

[cam_wmh]

Hot Take: Gilmour over Nieuwendyk in 89.

[Buff]

Originally Posted by timbit

Where is Fleury???

He lost my respect. I no longer want to give him any recognition no matter how good he was as a player 30 years ago.

[Buff]

Originally Posted by cam_wmh

Hot Take: Gilmour over Nieuwendyk in 89.

Very good debate.

However I chose Nilson over Gilmour because Gilmour wasn't an all-star during his time in Calgary.

[Winsor_Pilates]

Nobody(2001) - Val Bure - Nobody(2011)
Rautakallio - Phaneuf
Mike Smith

[Eric Vail]

Originally Posted by cam_wmh

Hot Take: Gilmour over Nieuwendyk in 89.

Gilmour was a far more complete player. He was outstanding defensively and still put up more points. Gilmour's line often went head to head with the opposition's best. Otto's line did too. Gilmour was a +45.

Nieuwendyk scored a lot of goals, but was a young player who hadn't mastered the defensive side of the game yet. He was a +26 on the year.

In the playoffs, Gilmour had 22 points and led the team with a +12.
Nieuwendyk had 14 points and was a +/- of zero.

Gilmour was the better player. Nieuwendyk improved as the years went on, but you could argue that Gilmour took his game to another level in Toronto as well.

[powderjunkie]

04 Iginla - 08 Iginla - 02 Iginla
90 MacInnis - 94 MacInnis
07 Kipper

Kinda crazy that Kipper is only there once.

[Strange Brew]

Originally Posted by cam_wmh

Hot Take: Gilmour over Nieuwendyk in 89.

Is that a hot take? At that point Gilmour was a far more complete player and definitely a much bigger part of the playoff run.

I recall a story that there was a conversation before game 6 with a few Flames about the "I'm going to Disneyland" promo they needed to do should they win the game and be awarded the Conn Smythe. I believe it was Macinnis, Vernon, Gilmour, Mullen and Otto they spoke with.

[tvp2003]

Some random Flames all-star memories:

- Kipper unveiling his new Vaughn pads with the V3 graphic at the 2007 ASG.

- Johnny getting added as an injury replacement during his rookie year, and then "scoring" on a breakaway in the Skills Challenge thanks to Jakub Voracek.

I was too young for the All-star Game that was held at the Saddledome in 1985; if we do end up getting a new arena in 2031 I'll be looking forward to having it return to Calgary.

[CSharp]

Originally Posted by Finger Cookin

1st team is Matthew Phillips, at every position.

2nd team is Jakob Pelletier, at every position.

Wait...you forgot Bennet! Takes 3 to make a line or is it 3's a crowd?