Quote:
Originally Posted by The Yen Man
I guess I'm also in the reserve judgement until Avs actually go anywhere. Great team on paper, but I still don't like their goaltending, and their defence didn't look too hot in this year's playoffs. Sure, there's oodles of potential there, but let see them actually put it all together before we crown Sakic king of gms.
Avs got REAL lucky with a few things:
1.) Tanking to get MacKinnon.
2.) MacKinnon being a late bloomer, so he signs (at the time) a market deal that is now one of the best contracts in the league.
3.) MacKinnon being a late bloomer and so the Avs suck for a few more years so they can draft top 5 multiple times.
Those aren't savy GM moves. They're just lucky situations.
|
Ah, thats a bit simplistic.
Avs exploded and won the West with Mackinnon and company. After a poor showing in the playoffs, Sakic signed Iginla to a reasonable 3 year contract as a veteran leader to help the young core. They didn’t have immediate success, and Sakic continued to not over commit to free agents and hurt the team’s long-term development. He was also patient and absolutely nailed the Duchene trade in a major way and continues to be one of the smartest trading general managers out there.
Sure, drafting Mackinnon was absolutely massive - but he’s done a good job of not pushing the fast forward button by trading away the future at the wrong time, and just generally being a top level general manager.
In comparison, Treliving screwed up by:
- Hiring Glen Gulutzan
- Acquiring Brian Elliott (horrible goaltender, poor pro scouting)
- Signing Troy Brouwer (horrible free agent signing, poor pro scouting)
- Trading for Travis Hamonic (huge overspend, poor pro scouting)
- Signing James Neal (worst free agent signing in team history, poor pro scouting)
Yeah, it’s not a huge list of mistakes - but it’s enough to damage a rebuild’s momentum. Absolutely putrid performance in free agency and inability to properly identify good value goaltenders when top-tier goaltending isn’t available has hurt this team almost every off-season since Treliving took over....and yeah, hiring Gulutzan was a gigantic disaster. One notable mistake each off-season is the difference between a top-end general manager, and a middling one.