The Athletic - The Brett Kulak miscalculation

[DeluxeMoustache]

^ *Guys who appear in scrums I am counting as journalists :-)

I will back away from all of this. I just don’t personally find much insight in the work of the author.

[Geeoff]

Montreal miscalculating Kulak too obviously.

[Freeway]

Originally Posted by DeluxeMoustache

^ *Guys who appear in scrums I am counting as journalists :-)

I will back away from all of this. I just don’t personally find much insight in the work of the author.

I think it's always a good idea to read things critically and examine the perspective of the author(s) thoughtfully. We can always thoughtfully disagree with media members and colleagues without getting nasty about it. Heck, thoughtful disagreement is often what generates better content from everybody.

[Redrum]

Originally Posted by Freeway

I think it's always a good idea to read things critically and examine the perspective of the author(s) thoughtfully. We can always thoughtfully disagree with media members and colleagues without getting nasty about it. Heck, thoughtful disagreement is often what generates better content from everybody.

Nuh-uh.

[EldrickOnIce]

Yes. That is true. And I have a lot of thoughtful disagreement with pretty much everything that particular journalist writes.

[dammage79]

I dont mind Haynes at all. He swings a lot from one side to the other. Some thing I agree with, some I dont. Hes not the kind of writer that thinks he is right and holds his opinion high, he just poops stuff out that he thinks is worthy. And hes one of the nicer ones that gives a little back and forth on twitter. Respectable IMO.

Although in this case, like Byron, it's a dead horse on a slow news day. CP needs no help lamenting the past.

Tree did well to move Kulak, he was the definition of tweener at the time. And now we have legit guys like Andersson and Kylington to help forget Kulak.

[AC]

Originally Posted by dammage79

I dont mind Haynes at all. He swings a lot from one side to the other. Some thing I agree with, some I dont. Hes not the kind of writer that thinks he is right and holds his opinion high, he just poops stuff out that he thinks is worthy. And hes one of the nicer ones that gives a little back and forth on twitter. Respectable IMO.

Although in this case, like Byron, it's a dead horse on a slow news day. CP needs no help lamenting the past.

Tree did well to move Kulak, he was the definition of tweener at the time. And now we have legit guys like Andersson and Kylington to help forget Kulak.

FYI the Kulak article in the OP is from Kent Wilson.

Not sure if you're confused about that. Haynes just posted the Tweet pointing out Kulak has been healthy'd 3 times already.