Quote:
Originally Posted by Erick Estrada
I don't know. I liked Starship Troopers and Machete because they were winking at you the entire time full of funny one-liners and some ridiculous scenes (Machete). It appeared Del Toro was attempting to make a fun (not funny) but serious Sci-Fi movie and unfortunately it was on the level of Starship Troopers without the humour and I still stand by my opinion that the acting as some of the worst I've seen in a movie of this budget. I generally like his work so I'm hoping that in the sequel if he decides to at least upgrade the story and spend some of the budget on actors.
|
I think the problem is del Toro wrote it as a nod to shows a lot of the audience has not seen. He openly admits it's a love letter to the old animated robot shows he knew as a child. This didn't include Transformers which is the mecha show most people are familiar with.
It's very visible in the mecha designs. For example, the one shown in the flashbacks clearly references the old Gundam show's Guncannon (del Toro admitting the connection...and then pointing out ones I didn't even notice). Heck, even the posters look like box art for collectible figurines and set the stage for a movie that is heavily influenced by eastern mecha media.
The narrative, tropes in place, is very much paint-by-numbers. Every twist did not have any emphasis and fell into the category of "knew it already". He didn't go for comedy but it didn't feel like he really wanted you to care about it either. The feeling I got that was that he wanted to make it so cliche and predictable that you didn't really care...the same way I don't think anybody couldn't predict Independence Day outside of the egregious use of Macs. Of course, Independence Day also had better actors to smooth over the corny dialogue.