CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by starseed

It is an excellent idea for the mafia. They confirmed their characters, know for a fact that it is random. They decide it would be good criteria to add suspicion to players who haven't considered whether the reveal is a good idea/safe, and then delay.

Except the mod said there was no risk, so there was no risk...We've been told he's not a ####### mod.

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by starseed

It is an excellent idea for the mafia. They confirmed their characters, know for a fact that it is random. They decide it would be good criteria to add suspicion to players who haven't considered whether the reveal is a good idea/safe, and then delay.

But my point is everyone knew for a fact that is was random. It was in the very first post in the game, and as Oiling points out, Mazrim confirmed it very early on as well.

If there was no upfront disclosure about the random character alignment, then I think it would have been a solid theory. But the big assumption in your theory is only the mafia knew alignments did not match their characters, when that is known to not be the case.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Except the mod said there was no risk, so there was no risk...We've been told he's not a ####### mod.

lol

Whether or not he is a #######, the post was long, and I cannot be the only one who didnt read it fully, or skim.

Yes, eventually it was clarified for everyone, however I am sure that there were people like me who were unsure of whether or not to reveal.

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

I don't know exactly what was said, but that's an absolute horrible metaphor. Drury18, does the quote seem to suggest that it was a metaphor?

Are we speaking of the comment by MOT #2 about the portal and dead speaking?

If so, when I read what I copy and pasted directly from that thread, it seems like a suggestion that anyone that has been killed or died in the game may use the portal to communicate to the living and that we should look further into that possibility.

It seems posed very much like their comment about the people to investigate. Here is a theory and go investigate them.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

But my point is everyone knew for a fact that is was random. It was in the very first post in the game, and as Oiling points out, Mazrim confirmed it very early on as well.

If there was no upfront disclosure about the random character alignment, then I think it would have been a solid theory. But the big assumption in your theory is only the mafia knew alignments did not match their characters, when that is known to not be the case.

My point is that the mafia could have talked about this openly in the thread early on, then reassured each other that it was safe to reveal. They then jumped in to get a solid non-mafia list of people to vote for.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

If so, when I read what I copy and pasted directly from that thread, it seems like a suggestion that anyone that has been killed or died in the game may use the portal to communicate to the living and that we should look further into that possibility.

Yeah, that's what I thought.

It seems set up for them to post in the next twilight thread as someone 'dead.'

I have a good feeling if Starseed didn't get targeted tonight for the lynch that a fake Dregar would have joined us in the twilight thread.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by starseed

My point is that the mafia could have talked about this openly in the thread early on, then reassured each other that it was safe to reveal. They then jumped in to get a solid non-mafia list of people to vote for.

Mazrim posted there was no risk in revealing. Why wouldn't everyone reveal? Only 1 person didn't right away. Grasping at straws here Starseed...

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Drury18

Are we speaking of the comment by MOT #2 about the portal and dead speaking?

If so, when I read what I copy and pasted directly from that thread, it seems like a suggestion that anyone that has been killed or died in the game may use the portal to communicate to the living and that we should look further into that possibility.

It seems posed very much like their comment about the people to investigate. Here is a theory and go investigate them.

I do not know what they MOT2 was getting at, but it seems to me like they are saying it may be a way for the dead to give us info. That info being who killed them.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by starseed

I do not know what they MOT2 was getting at, but it seems to me like they are saying it may be a way for the dead to give us info. That info being who killed them.

Interesting slip up starseed.

They? Why would you refer to as an individual as "they" at first?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by starseed

I do not know what they MOT2 was getting at, but it seems to me like they are saying it may be a way for the dead to give us info. That info being who killed them.

Why are you referring to 1 person, at least according to you, as they?

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Yeah, that's what I thought.

It seems set up for them to post in the next twilight thread as someone 'dead.'

I have a good feeling if Starseed didn't get targeted tonight for the lynch that a fake Dregar would have joined us in the twilight thread.

That would probably have shot the MOT credibility. If I were mafia, I would have considered that way too risky. Why potentially destabilize what the MOT thread was building? It would be a terrible mafia move.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Why are you referring to 1 person, at least according to you, as they?

I keep going between gender neutral to MOT2. I am not going to reveal anything about MOT2.

[Wood]

Originally Posted by starseed

I do not know what they MOT2 was getting at, but it seems to me like they are saying it may be a way for the dead to give us info. That info being who killed them.

Are you guys supposed to be masons? Why are you not on the same page?

[GGG]

How many votes are on Starseed?

[Wood]

Not sure but I'm unvoting for now

unvote

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Wood

Are you guys supposed to be masons? Why are you not on the same page?

I was going to reveal about the vote thing, and MOT2 was going to reveal the dead investigation thing. We didnt specifically state what we were going to say.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by starseed

lol

Whether or not he is a #######, the post was long, and I cannot be the only one who didnt read it fully, or skim.

Yes, eventually it was clarified for everyone, however I am sure that there were people like me who were unsure of whether or not to reveal.

Originally Posted by Mazrim

As I said in the OP, your character is not necessarily indicative of role or alignment, so there should be no fear over revealing your character.

This was the post. The entirety of the post. This is what Mazrim said before the collective town revealed characters. There was no risk, we were told. Your argument doesn't hold water.

[dissentowner]

I told you the MOT could not be trusted..

[mrkajz44]

Here's my big worry about this reveal. Since it's happened, the conversation has been with only a handful of people. Where is everyone else? Why is no one else jumping into this conversation? It says there are 12 members viewing right now, but only 4 are listed, so 8 people are in this thread as invisible, which I think means 8 other people are watching but not participating.

What if Starseed is telling the truth and just being clumsy about it? The mafia would love this - the thread is getting full of talk and they don't even have to do anything about it.

I'd like to hear some more people chime in on the situation and provide some more discussion rather than a few people just talking back and forth with Starseed. Personally, I think it smells fishy and I'm not sure I believe him. I'll sleep on it and see how I feel in the morning, but I still see it as a scummy diversion.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

This was the post. The entirety of the post. This is what Mazrim said before the collective town revealed characters. There was no risk, we were told. Your argument doesn't hold water.

For some reason I thought that reassurance message was in between the reveals.