Ok, so I have a few minutes before I hit the road for the afternoon and want to make my case. I understand that this is based off evidence brought forth by Starseed, but nothing I have seen since that point has indicated to me otherwise, but has further served to solidify my opinion.
My original post, post starseed lynch:
http://forum.calgarypuck.com/showpos...postcount=1548
I am just copying the contents of that post here, so if it seems familar, thats why. Will save on retyping.
CaptainCrunch
If I was mafia and playing it like starseed did, I would actually try and play (and think) like a townie so I would be able to pull the big deception like he did. That means targetting someone you actually think is mafia (obviously Barrow in this case). He would have had help with other mafia to develop his theory, which is why his final posts were in such detail. An added bonus to this is that he would have an advantage picking out Barrow mafia since he was able to automatically remove his own team from the list. Because of this, I suspect that his accusation against CaptainCrunch isn't nessecarily something to be disregarded, because if he dies and flips mafia before starseed does, he looks like a hero and directs attention away from himself. Everything he said made a lot of sense.
To briefly summarize:
- Started on Agulati (expanded upon by me, here -
http://forum.calgarypuck.com/showpos...postcount=1521)
- Potential connection to Completely
- Potential hints to other mafia
- Other general odd posts
(complete posting here -
http://forum.calgarypuck.com/showpos...postcount=1514)
addtionally, other things brought up by other posters:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lego Man
CaptainCrunch seems to be entirely sidetracked and focusing on the wrong things all game. He's too clueless to be Mafia. That is my opinion at least.
|
Here, he doesn't say that CC is mafia, but he points out that he seems clueless. One thing I know about CC is he never appears clueless, even if he is wrong. Since then, he has continued with the baseless accusations posting of little content. Doesn't scream town to me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch
Fine, We need to see what Starseed is, it opens some things up in terms of who to go after next if he flips up mob.
unvote
vote Starseed
|
Here, CC hammered starseed. His hammer to try and stop the accusations of starseed is telling. I wonder if he fully suspected starseed as mafia as well, and thought it would clear him in the process. Since this time, CC has attacked me and tried to start a vote against me in hopes that it would derail my accusations. One more tactic being reused to stay alive.
Finally, today. We have the whole Baxter situation, where he should have died over night, completely independent of if he was telling the truth or not. If he was lying and was actually mafia, the other mafia would still kill him, unless they wanted to use the situation to sow dissension in the town.
The best result for the mafia is not to kill the Dr, which hasn't been overly useful all game, because it is hard as hell to figure out who is town, but to let him live and hopefully push their own agenda and have us lynch him ourselves.
The hammer on CBL was given by himself, but Completely threw out the final vote just before that. By itself, it doesn't mean anything, but CC then points out that it is the hammer. Again, another connection between CC and Completely.
This post, is another, trying to push CC theory:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Completely
I think CC just might have thrown himself to the wolves, But he has done some pretty good detective work. CC might be wrong with Agulati but at least he noticed the fault. And now Legoman has been acting funny and drawing attention to himself. I think that if the doctors out there we should keep CC in this, He's been actually helping figure out who's who. Not just wasting time slinging mud seeing if it sticks.
|
And now, this series of posts to start the day that have them both pushing the theory that somehow Baxter is suspicious because he didn't get killed:
Quote:
Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch
Lego is suspicious and has been quieting down his act and settling into the weeds. I find it odd that the mafia didn't kill Baxter even though he claims to be the doctor.
I still stand by my reasoning that Lego is dirty.
Vote: Legoman
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Completely
Anyone else extremely uncomfortable with the fact that Baxter is still alive after telling everyone hes the doctor? I know its pure speculation and we cant tell who each other are but it makes me a little uneasy. It's hard after CBL was so adamant that there was something wrong and no one really listened. Then he kills himself and flips town and For Bax not to die from a nightkill and then for Parker to have one left as well. I feel like we should all make a top 3 of who we think is suspicious. That way we have an idea of what direction we should go.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch
Lego - I've explained his suspicious posts and actions multiple times
Baxter - more around the fact that he wasn't night killed.
I'm torn on the third one I need to go back tomorrow night and look at HG15 and Strombad again.
|
My list for mafia is now
CaptainCrunch
Completely
Vote : CaptainCrunch
