CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Baxter Renegade]

^^^ and by these three, I mean CBL, LEGO and Kermit.

[dissentowner]

I am sticking to my vote, if we lynch CBL either way he flips should be really helpful for us and give us direction.

[jayswin]

Kermit has posted very short, and pointedly for most of the game and his posts just seem to always be steering away from people or into other people during times when certain posters are on trial.

This last thing where he's suggesting that cbl wouldn't go after Baxter if he was mafia is especially suspicious. Plus I asked him to clarify twice and he ignored both times, like Baxter stated.

I think batters right in that were probably looking at a mafia group in cbl/Legoman and Kermit. I think we need to hammer away at those three ( or at least start to until proven wrong by one of their flips).

But one problem. Me and Baxter definitely look suspicious together now and cbl is leafing that charge (obviously). So that leaves us with a couple of options.

Cbl first. See what happens.

Flameswin. I think this option is very beneficial. Even more so now. It will seperate me and Baxter once I flip, plus Baxter will likely be dead anyways. So then the remaining town can focus solely on those three.

What does everyone think? Stick with cbl? Go with me to remove suspicion and then focus on those three?

[Completely]

Well that was an eventful weekend, it was like 4 people pointing guns at eachother.

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

I had to explain this to Kermit a few times before he unvoted... We fought a bit.

Your logic didn't make sense at first to me either.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by flameswin

Flameswin. I think this option is very beneficial. Even more so now. It will seperate me and Baxter once I flip, plus Baxter will likely be dead anyways. So then the remaining town can focus solely on those three.

You are the most suicidal player I have ever seen. I have never seen a player want to die so bad. I am still voting CBL.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

You are the most suicidal player I have ever seen. I have never seen a player want to die so bad. I am still voting CBL.

Haha, yeah, well it just remove so much doubt and allow the remaining group to nail CBL, Legoman and Kermitology without the distraction of me being in the way.

Right now I see it going like this;

Baxter flips mafia. We spend all of day 6 with accusations of me being Baxter's butt buddy (accusations that are already in full swing, see; CBL). Then we end day 6 with my death and we're screwed beyond belief that late in the game.

Either way, my vote is still with CBL and hopefully if he flips town everyone doesn't forget this and we go after Legoman and Kermitology immediately after.

Or CBL flips town and I'm the goat.

[jayswin]

*flips mafia

[Baxter Renegade]

If flameswin is in fact mafia, I highly doubt the other member(s) of his faction would be on board for having him sacrifice himself. That would be a bad play on their part.

That being said, my flip at night will clear Flameswin and I of any affiliation. Flameswin's very town based actions should allow everyone to stay the course.

We got this.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Rathji

Your logic didn't make sense at first to me either.

It wasn't MY logic... Just logic.

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

It wasn't MY logic... Just logic.

Your logic didn't make THE logic very clear.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Rathji

Your logic didn't make THE logic very clear.

Well I'm glad everyone got it figured out.

[Mazrim]

Originally Posted by flameswin

But if CBL is town I will literally take a dump on a plate and eat it for breakfast.

Please don't say stuff like that, sarcastically or not. Check the rules.

[jayswin]

Okay. Sorry.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by flameswin

Okay. Sorry.

haha you got in trouble....

[undercoverbrother]

Ok, I have done some thinking and reading. My main issue is I don't trust CBL.

He has "all night" to come up with his ideas/reasons to kill Flameswin, but when Flameswin agrees he turns 180 and picks another individual.

Flameswin knows that even when "dead" he still wins when the town wins.

unvote

vote: crazybaconlegs

[Hockeyguy15]

Looks like the group has spoken, I will wait to vote until CBL has a chance to post one last defense.

Kind funny though, if CBL flips town a few posters will use it as another reason to be suspicious of me because it would be another town lynch I am part of.

[CaptainCrunch]

It is interesting with the Baxter doctor thing, because no matter what he does I think he's dead. If he's lying and mafia, the opposing mafia group has to kill him to be sure, if he's telling the truth I don't think he can protect himself (right) I think the best hope at that point is that both mafia's trip over each other to kill him and there's only one night kill instead of two.

If Baxter is the doctor, it was a foolish move for him to role flip like he did, because he went from being the target of one group that he might have been able to prove himself out of to the target of all three. If he's a mob player lying to cloud the waters then it was a really bad gamble that has completely doomed himself.

I can see the case against CBL, I don't think its strong enough for me to remove my conviction that Lego is dirty so I'm going to just sit on that one for a while.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

It is interesting with the Baxter doctor thing, because no matter what he does I think he's dead. If he's lying and mafia, the opposing mafia group has to kill him to be sure, if he's telling the truth I don't think he can protect himself (right) I think the best hope at that point is that both mafia's trip over each other to kill him and there's only one night kill instead of two.

If Baxter is the doctor, it was a foolish move for him to role flip like he did, because he went from being the target of one group that he might have been able to prove himself out of to the target of all three. If he's a mob player lying to cloud the waters then it was a really bad gamble that has completely doomed himself.

I can see the case against CBL, I don't think its strong enough for me to remove my conviction that Lego is dirty so I'm going to just sit on that one for a while.

I was about to be lynched. I would have had to somehow proved my affiliation to everyone, not just one group. As this game has blatantly shown, there's no coming back from a hammer lynch... I had to reveal to ensure we could go forward with lynching mafia. If I stayed quiet and got lynched, the mafia gets one heck of a good day, followed by an unhindered night of murdering. With my reveal, we get to lynch mafia instead and it creates an issue with their night kills. I don't see how this is foolish given the following:

Option A: Day 5 = Doctor lynched, Night 5 = Townsperson X killed, Townsperson Y killed (probably, mafia cross fire possible but not likely from a stats point of view)

Option B: Day 5 = Potential to lynch a mafia, Night 5 = Both mafia kill doctor (likely)

Option B potentially saves 2 townies.

It's the only way to help the town given the circumstances.

I think my decision to announce my role will prove to be incredibly valuable to the town as it uncovered TONS of information... Day 5 is a treasure trove of slip ups, affiliations and misunderstandings. If played correctly, it could be the day that wins it for the town.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 17 alive, it takes 9 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 6 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (4): CofR, ineedanother, Completely, Hockeyguy15

Voting:
Crazy Bacon Legs (6): Baxter Renegade, Oling_Roachinen, Rathji, dissentowner, flameswin, undercoverbrother
Baxter Renegade (3): Crazy Bacon Legs, strombad, Lego Man
Lego Man (3): DropIt, CaptainCrunch, HalifaxDrunk
Oling_Roachinen (1): kermitology

Deadline is Tuesday, May 20th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.