CP Mafia 4 - The Unknown Host - Game Over!

[GGG]

The name 3 and let pux pick is terrible. It allows Scum to hide who they are really voting for and pux although genuine is bot necessarily right. Everyone should be comfortable with their own evaluation much as they are with pux's.

If you are town why would you trust a known towny over yourself a known towny.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by SebC

I've sent Mazrim a PM. I want to disclose this before he might say anything about it here so you know it was my idea. I think the town might have a shot to win the game today.

Any reason you can't share it on a hypothetical basis so we can discuss prior to Mazrim getting back to you? That would also give the scum less time to counter plan in their own thread.

[Timbo]

If we lynch to Capt while he has the spore does the 2IC have to kill the engineer to gain it back?
If so , that might be what SebC is questioning

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by Timbo

If we lynch to Capt while he has the spore does the 2IC have to kill the engineer to gain it back?
If so , that might be what SebC is questioning

Even if that were true, that would only be two of the three host, the second in command would still be alive. Seb would realize this, so I doubt that's it.

All that being said, and I'm a pretty big supporter of Seb, but if he knows who the captain is I think he should tell us now and not worry about what Mazrim says.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by bizaro86

Even if that were true, that would only be two of the three host, the second in command would still be alive. Seb would realize this, so I doubt that's it.

All that being said, and I'm a pretty big supporter of Seb, but if he knows who the captain is I think he should tell us now and not worry about what Mazrim says.

Agreed, I am just trying to see what he is thinking as I just see it as another cryptic post.
Going over the rules I can't see a way to get three Hosts in one day.
As cool as that would be, I don't see it possible

[Oling_Roachinen]

If we were to lynch the captain today, the person who receives the spore (assuming unturned) sends the spore to 'carrier'.

We kill 'carrier' with the spore, ridding ourselves of the spore forever because they have no turned to change.

If the Captain is dead when the holder of the spore is lynched, the Second in Command can receive the spore ONLY by killing a turned player, and he must also wait a day. The Engineer is the same, after the Second in Command dies.

That wouldn't win us the game though, as we would still need to kill the other 2 hosts.

[SebC]

Originally Posted by bizaro86

Even if that were true, that would only be two of the three host, the second in command would still be alive. Seb would realize this, so I doubt that's it.

You caught my mistake before I did. It wouldn't outright win the game, but it perhaps it would perma-stop the spore.

Second in command cannot kill the engineer - the hosts are explicitly not turned.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by SebC

You caught my mistake before I did. It wouldn't outright win the game, but it perhaps it would perma-stop the spore.

Second in command cannot kill the engineer - the hosts are explicitly not turned.

So then from your first post on this do you know who the Capt is?
And if you do please share!

[SebC]

I do not know who the captain is - that would only be possible if I were scum.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Well based on the wording "If the Captain is dead when the holder of the spore is lynched..." if we killed Captain would he count as the holder of the spore? I guess probably so yeah, lynch him and spore is gone right away.

Should focus our goal on tracking 'Captain' today as opposed to the other hosts. This will come off really bad if Hockeyguy15 is Host, but I think those going for him should refocus their attention to someone more inconspicuous because if he is host, he's probably not putting himself so out there as the captain...although I guess I did last time as Godfather.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

I'm just horrible at keeping secrets. Look at how I screwed up my mason power last game? I just couldn't see any reason to stay revealed. It's a useless power except to keep the spore out of play. But that is moot right now if we can believe Oling passed the spore to Girly, because with her dying before she could pass it, it went back to the Captain. I hope the GA investigated Oling. I would hope he (or she) is staying quiet because nobody has been turned on who they checked out. They really don't need to reveal. Whenever someone dies, we know that they've done their job.
I would agree to be the hammer on one of the 2 or 3 suspects that you guys could agree on.
What I would like to see is HG STFU for a little bit and get more talk from everyone else. Especially Lego Man. Don't say your quality is better than quantity. I think the less posts someone makes it's easier to hide. When you make one post a day, you have 24 hours to form a well thought out message that has no slips. Nice way to make sure you don't screw up. I would say the bottom third of the players need to stop posting more. And don't say it's noise!!!!! That's BS! That is how we hunt scum!

I'll STFU when other people (including you) step up. Deal?

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by SebC

I do not know who the captain is - that would only be possible if I were scum.

I will put this as simple as I can so that I don't get another
Of your cryptic posts.
You believed we had a shot to win this game (from your mistaken take on the rules)
So in order to have that true you must have a strong suspicion on who the Captain is. If so please share that.

[Oling_Roachinen]

If I was going strictly for 'Captain' I think my vote would come down to East Coast Flame or Dissentowner as they've been the most inconspicuous.

I feel like the most 'out there' East Coast Flame has been was voting early for GirlySports but that was after Sebc's vote and unvote, and my vote, so even as an early voter he wouldn't get as much attention. Other than that, I can't really recall what he's done (of course it's early still).

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Well based on the wording "If the Captain is dead when the holder of the spore is lynched..." if we killed Captain would he count as the holder of the spore? I guess probably so yeah, lynch him and spore is gone right away.

Should focus our goal on tracking 'Captain' today as opposed to the other hosts. This will come off really bad if Hockeyguy15 is Host, but I think those going for him should refocus their attention to someone more inconspicuous because if he is host, he's probably not putting himself so out there as the captain...although I guess I did last time as Godfather.

This day we should focus on hunting hosts!
Any one of the three would be a major success at the end of this day!

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Timbo

This day we should focus on hunting hosts!
Any one of the three would be a major success at the end of this day!

Okay, I'll keep my vote where it is

[SebC]

Originally Posted by Timbo

I will put this as simple as I can so that I don't get another
Of your cryptic posts.
You believed we had a shot to win this game (from your mistaken take on the rules)
So in order to have that true you must have a strong suspicion on who the Captain is. If so please share that.

A shot is a mathematically non-zero probability, far from a strong suspicion. This time, it is your deduction that is erroneous.

[devo22]

Another example of why SebCs posting style makes me want to roundhouse kick a lion. And I'm a fan of the Three Lions, so that's some kind of feat. The only good thing here is that in my opinion, he's as much confirmed town as possible at this point. There's simply no way that two other scum members would let him post like that.

[East Coast Flame]

Originally Posted by SebC

A shot is a mathematically non-zero probability, far from a strong suspicion. This time, it is your deduction that is erroneous.

Awesome contribution, as always

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I'll STFU when other people (including you) step up. Deal?

Step up? I could reply with a "Come at me bro!" but I think I'm above that. I'm sorry if I've gotten under your skin (spore joke). I will just keep playing like I have.

[East Coast Flame]

I guess I'm getting some flack for being inconspicuous, so I'll try and get the ball rolling on who I think is the biggest target right now:

Vote: mrkajz44

Guy is the king of the drive by post. He wades in here, tries to get everyone side tracked or confused and then disappears.