Calgarypuck Mafia Game Thread

[Oling_Roachinen]

Day 4

With 9 posters, it takes 5 votes to ban user prior to deadline. It takes at least 3 votes to ban user at the deadline. A tied vote at deadline results in no banning.

Vote Count:


SebC(4): mrkajz44, Puxlut, WinnipegFan, Dropit

DropIt(2): Hockeyguy15, Scornfire

WinnipegFan(1): SebC

Hasn’t Voted (2):
devo22, agulati

Deadline is Sunday, February 3rd at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[SebC]

Originally Posted by devo22

has SebC explained his logic with "he'd be a good day 4 lynch" already? Something I'd be curious about.

Day 4 lynch GGG, day 5 it's okay if I'm mislynched if I'd been wrong and GGG flipped town, Day 6 earliest possible lynch-or-lose day with two mafia alive. Basically, lynching him Day 4 would've maximized his involvement in the game (for either strong townie play or possible mafia slips) while still giving us a shot to win in my worst-case scenario.

[SebC]

I guess I'll create options.

[SebC]

Remove vote: WinnipegFan

[SebC]

Vote: DropIt

3v4.... Anyone gonna jump on that? Could make for a last second upset!

[mrkajz44]

I'm locked in for SebC - no way I'm moving

Sent from my EML-L09 using Tapatalk

[Oling_Roachinen]

Day 4 has ended

With 9 posters, it takes 5 votes to ban user prior to deadline. It takes at least 3 votes to ban user at the deadline. A tied vote at deadline results in no banning.

Vote Count:

SebC(4): mrkajz44, Puxlut, WinnipegFan, Dropit

DropIt(3): Hockeyguy15, Scornfire, SebC

Hasn’t Voted (2):
devo22, agulati

[Oling_Roachinen]

[Oling_Roachinen]

Sorry for the late start. agulati was banned during the night.

It is now Day 5

With 7 posters, it takes 4 votes to ban user prior to deadline. It takes at least 3 votes to ban user at the deadline. A tied vote at deadline results in no banning.

Vote Count:

Votes(0)

Hasn’t Voted (9):
Puxlut, Hockeyguy15, devo22, DropIt, WinnipegFan, mrkajz44, Scornfire

Deadline is Thursday, February 7th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[DropIt]

Damn. Our hot streak has ground to a halt.

No votes from Devo or Ags and one of them is gone. I can't imagine the last mafia member wouldn't have cast a vote.

In starting to wonder how HG, being as experienced and good at this game as I've heard he is, is still in this game if he is town. It seems in the best interest of the last mafia member to weed out the strong players and get the town down to new players.

I cant imagine devo is mafia without casting a vote, unless he was fine with the result as long as he wasnt up there.

[devo22]

my non-vote was primarily down to it being a pretty busy weekend and then no movement while I was on during the Super Bowl. At that point, SebC (who was my prime suspect anyway) was a shoe-in to be lynched and I went to bed.

let's get some discussion going and finish this today.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by DropIt

Damn. Our hot streak has ground to a halt.

No votes from Devo or Ags and one of them is gone. I can't imagine the last mafia member wouldn't have cast a vote.

In starting to wonder how HG, being as experienced and good at this game as I've heard he is, is still in this game if he is town. It seems in the best interest of the last mafia member to weed out the strong players and get the town down to new players.

I cant imagine devo is mafia without casting a vote, unless he was fine with the result as long as he wasnt up there.

Looking at the list of kills bizaro was day 1 and I'm willing to bet a GGG ordered kill on a strong player, day 2 was dissnetowner who was basically confirmed town, day 3 was Fuzz who was the only confirmed town, day 4 agulati who I don't think anyone suspected to not be town?

Seems more like to me they are trying to pick off the most confirmed town people rather than strong players.

[Hockeyguy15]

Having said that, maybe I am barking up the wrong tree focusing on GGG being with two new people? If I'm trying to get everyone to look at that and I'm wrong maybe it's good to keep me around?

Originally Posted by DropIt

Damn. Our hot streak has ground to a halt.

No votes from Devo or Ags and one of them is gone. I can't imagine the last mafia member wouldn't have cast a vote.

In starting to wonder how HG, being as experienced and good at this game as I've heard he is, is still in this game if he is town. It seems in the best interest of the last mafia member to weed out the strong players and get the town down to new players.

I cant imagine devo is mafia without casting a vote, unless he was fine with the result as long as he wasnt up there.

There's only one coiler left. Doesn't matter who he votes for. It's not like he's lynching anyone during the day. And Seb was pretty much a sure thing.

[Hockeyguy15]

I probably won't have time to do any indepth re-reading today (have a lot of stuff due on work day 3) but tomorrow I will have a bunch of time to do my digging.

[mrkajz44]

Hmmm - I was so sure of SebC but here we are. So far my tactic of focusing on voting patterns has gotten me nowhere. I think I might need to abandon that way of thinking. It didn't tip me off to either Bonded nor GGG. It's also lead me to target agulati and SebC, now both confirmed town.

I see the banning of agulati last night as picking off someone who doesn't provide a lot of information to us. Day 4 agulati didn't have a ton of posts; most of them were regarding SebC, who was just banned, so that doesn't help us in the near term. He also didn't vote (though he did say he was going to vote SebC but didn't want hammer), so there's not much to gather there. I'm not sure a review of all his posts will produce something, but it'll be helpful to put the Flames lens on his posts.

I think I need a re-read of everything here to try and formulate a plan. My hunch is we are looking for someone who has kept relatively quiet all game and continues to just lie in the weeds. Just a hunch right now though.

Votes Scornfire (4): Hockeyguy15, SebC, devo22, bizaro86

Votes agulati (5): Winnipegfan, mrkajz44, Bonded, GGG, crazy_eoj

Votes Bonded (6): dissentowner, agulati, Fuzz, Puxlut, DropIt, Scornfire

I think the first day gave us the most info. Because people are not voting or not changing votes, doesn't help with patterns.
Scorn could have voted agulati (known town) to cause a lynch but instead voted Bonded. I don't think a greaser would do that, that early in the game. There's no way thy would sacrifice one of their own on the first day? Same argument for Drop it...
Which leaves HG, WF and MrK.
Out of those 3, the one that has consistently voted for known Flames or unknown people is MrK.

Vote: mrkajz44

Sorry, devo should have been included in there too. But he voted GGG twice on day 2, so I'll stick to my vote.