Calgarypuck Mafia Game Thread

[Fuzz]

Ya, I am having a tough time today as well. Eoj, WF, Scornfire, and SebC have all given reasons they may be greasers, as discussed at length by others. And this is far from my conclusive list. Nothing Puxlut has done or said makes much sense to me(sorry!) but I'm not sure it's greasiness that is the problem. Going to sit tight for now.

Just a few things that just doesn't sit right with me. He seems wishy/washy, flippy/floppy. And just a couple of posts that he "slipped" on. He's played the game before and I would have thought he would have posted more thorough.
Again, I don't know how to multi quote, so will have to cut and paste:

#561-"As such, they decided as a group to sacrifice Bonded as one Oiler down was better than 2." Oilers didn't sacrifice Bonded. Neither of them voted for him.

#522 "Especially surprised with a self-hammer." As a seasoned player, why would it surprise you. He knew he was screwed and wanted to stop any more chat before night time.

#485 "Sorry - totally forgot about hammer with my post. I quickly just looked at who hadn't voted from Oling's summary. Not trying to push hammer." Then why not take your vote off.

#475 "I would like to see HG be checked by the mod, unless things move of GGG today for someone else. Then I'd like to see GGG checked." Why throw HG out there for the Mod? To lure Fuzz away from checking GGG?

#359 "Haha - yes, indeed. Got the tally messed up - apologies everyone!

I'm not a huge fan of voting out Bonded, but I'm willing to move my vote if required to avoid the potential of a tie vote. Moving from agulati to Bonded would make the vote 7-4-4 (double checked the numbers that time!) and would make a tie very difficult." WHOOPS! Another mistake? He's better than that.

Then there were a bunch of posts against Diss on day one... There is someone else that could be a vote I could flip to.

And it's ok Fuzz. Sometimes I don't make much sense to myself

[agulati]

^That is your reasoning for mrk, correct?

You know what would be funny: If Diss was the Mod. And the Coiler's just got lucky on their first ban. And then Fuzz and GGG set it up to cement everyone's thought that Fuzz was the Mod? An ultimate sacrifice to make sure a greaser made it to the end.

Originally Posted by agulati

^That is your reasoning for mrk, correct?

Sorry, yes.

I am willing to change my vote to another later. I just wanted to make sure I had a vote on if there was a hammer.

[Scornfire]

I think the death post would inform us that Diss was the mod if that was the case

Originally Posted by Scornfire

I think the death post would inform us that Diss was the mod if that was the case

####. I even got the name wrong. I meant Biz. But yeah, It says regular fan. Anyways... I have to zip out. I will try and get back this arvo.

[Hockeyguy15]

Devo and Scornfire looking back at the timing of the crazy_eoj vote on GGG the only players not on GGG were GGG and Seb. Seb had just said he was willing to pull and obviously GGG wasn't going to hammer himself until he was ready so neither of them would be hammering GGG.

The non-voters were Puxlut, Dropit, Scornfire and agulati. Puxlut and agulati should know not to hammer from previous experience so they weren't threats. That leaves Dropit and Scornfire as potential hammers. Eoj really had no choice but to get on at that point or he could be left off completely. He had posted once and at that point GGG had 1 vote on him, then he comes back and the votes had been piling up on GGG so he could have been scrambling.

[crazy_eoj]

Originally Posted by Scornfire

I think the death post would inform us that Diss was the mod if that was the case

It also shows on the first post who eliminated users were:

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Welcome to Calgarypuck where your Regular Flame Fans have signed up to discuss how amazing their conference-leading team is.

However, as it's no longer October, the Oilers sit outside the playoffs. Disgruntled Oiler Fans have grown even more disillusioned with their 8th rebuild this decade and have decided to take out their anger on CP. Their only purpose is to sow distrust on CP to get other users banned and they have created fake accounts to do so.

CP has employed a moderator to go undercover to stomp out the trolls. This moderator will be able to investigate other users IP addresses once per night to see if they are located in Calgary or Edmonton.

There are 2 Common Trolls and one Proxy Troll. The proxy troll is particularly technology savvy and has been able to find a Calgary proxy to disguise his true location from the moderator.

Roles:
11 Common Users
1 Moderator
2 Common Trolls
1 Proxy Troll

Active posters:
1. Puxlut
2. Hockeyguy15
3. Fuzz
5. SebC
7. devo22
9. DropIt
10. WinnipegFan
11. mrkajz44
12. Scornfire
13. agulati
15. crazy_eoj

Banned posters:
6. Bonded aka 69McDavidLover420 - Common Troll - Day 1
8. bizaro86 - Common User - Night 1
4. GGG aka IginlaSucksYOLO - Common Troll - Day 2
14. dissentowner- Common User - Night 2

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

Just a few things that just doesn't sit right with me. He seems wishy/washy, flippy/floppy. And just a couple of posts that he "slipped" on. He's played the game before and I would have thought he would have posted more thorough.
Again, I don't know how to multi quote, so will have to cut and paste:

#561-"As such, they decided as a group to sacrifice Bonded as one Oiler down was better than 2." Oilers didn't sacrifice Bonded. Neither of them voted for him.

#522 "Especially surprised with a self-hammer." As a seasoned player, why would it surprise you. He knew he was screwed and wanted to stop any more chat before night time.

#485 "Sorry - totally forgot about hammer with my post. I quickly just looked at who hadn't voted from Oling's summary. Not trying to push hammer." Then why not take your vote off.

#475 "I would like to see HG be checked by the mod, unless things move of GGG today for someone else. Then I'd like to see GGG checked." Why throw HG out there for the Mod? To lure Fuzz away from checking GGG?

#359 "Haha - yes, indeed. Got the tally messed up - apologies everyone!

I'm not a huge fan of voting out Bonded, but I'm willing to move my vote if required to avoid the potential of a tie vote. Moving from agulati to Bonded would make the vote 7-4-4 (double checked the numbers that time!) and would make a tie very difficult." WHOOPS! Another mistake? He's better than that.

Then there were a bunch of posts against Diss on day one... There is someone else that could be a vote I could flip to.

And it's ok Fuzz. Sometimes I don't make much sense to myself

I can comment on these. Not sure I agree with flippy/floppy - both times I've laid out my exact reasoning for my vote and I never changed votes each day.

#561 - I was saying they sacrificed Bonded based on my theory that the other Oiler was on Scornfire (not agulati). As such, a move off Scorn to agulati to force a tie would have saved Bonded, but this outs two Oilers (Bonded for being saved, as well as whomever moved of Scornfire). As such, my view was that the Oiler sacrificed Bonded

#522 - I truly was surprised with self-hammer. The two games I played were years ago and I didn't remember a self-hammer occurring. I didn't really consider a self vote to hammer yourself when I was reading what happened

#485 - The post speaks for itself - I've been trying to look at primarily votes to determine targets, since everything else can be fluff. I was out running errands and noticed there were still "no votes" sitting out there so I was looking for votes - I just forgot about hammer when quickly posting. I also wasn't on GGG (was on HG), so I couldn't take my vote off to avoid hammer

#475 - My posts on day 2 show that I thought HG was an Oiler. I put my vote to him on that day too. When discussing who the mod should look at and I saw that GGG was likely to be banned, I suggested my target. At that time I didn't know Fuzz was the mod either.

#359 - Not sure on this one? I did make a mistake in my eariler post about the numbers - that speaks for itself. My comment of moving to Bonded to make it 7-4-4 was correct, no? At the time it was 6-5-4 (Bonded, agulati, Scornfire), so my potential move from agulati to Bonded would have made it 7-4-4.

[mrkajz44]

Just something that came up when I was responding to Pux - when I was thinking of moving from agulati to Bonded on day 1 to help ensure there would be no tie, SebC was fairly quick to object to my move. I've already laid out my case against him, but this is something else that might be a mark against him. If I did indeed move to Bonded, his fate was almost surely sealed - however, without a move over, a tie was still a real possibility. I wonder if SebC's comment was to buy some Oiler time to try and save Bonded?

Yes, a bit of a stretch on that alone, but it makes me feel better about my vote.

[Fuzz]

Who were all the newbs?

[Scornfire]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Devo and Scornfire looking back at the timing of the crazy_eoj vote on GGG the only players not on GGG were GGG and Seb. Seb had just said he was willing to pull and obviously GGG wasn't going to hammer himself until he was ready so neither of them would be hammering GGG.

The non-voters were Puxlut, Dropit, Scornfire and agulati. Puxlut and agulati should know not to hammer from previous experience so they weren't threats. That leaves Dropit and Scornfire as potential hammers. Eoj really had no choice but to get on at that point or he could be left off completely. He had posted once and at that point GGG had 1 vote on him, then he comes back and the votes had been piling up on GGG so he could have been scrambling.

Why does GGG vote Crazy with very little reasoning as he's resigning to his fate, for his purposes he SHOULD be digging in against a veteran that's getting suspicion. He's building cases against just about every vet prior to this and there's easier/more believable cases he could have made. It came off as a misdirect and with Eoj having set up hammer (until devo took his vote off wisely) right before GGG promises us a good post later (he's already come up with mod reveal plan by now, and likely the plan b self ban) it lines up too well for me. He even calls out WF's post as reeking of "newscum" in post #424 the page prior, why would he have more cause to distrust Eoj than WF when he's voting as a purported flames fan at this point

[Scornfire]

Originally Posted by Fuzz

Who were all the newbs?

Us, Bonded/Eoj/Winnipegfan

[agulati]

I'm going to remove my vote from HG for now since it doesn't look like the town will focus on him for today, though I am still suspicious of him. We need a Lynch tonight, and I'm okay going with either Seb or Crazy. We don't need to hammer them though, so let us keep the conversation going, even if we make a decision.

[agulati]

Remove Vote: Hockeyguy15

[crazy_eoj]

Originally Posted by Bonded

Haven't much out of sebc or crazy_eoj. Silence is supposed to be bad. Fuzz is playing it how someone getting guided would be.



I think scorn is town for sure. Other than that I don't have a good read on anyone.

This post becomes very interesting based on where we are at right now? Bonded's last post before being lynched.

Of course the very next post after that night period ended was Scorn jumping out with an accusation against me that he built on bad information.

[Fuzz]

Originally Posted by agulati

I'm going to remove my vote from HG for now since it doesn't look like the town will focus on him for today, though I am still suspicious of him. We need a Lynch tonight, and I'm okay going with either Seb or Crazy. We don't need to hammer them though, so let us keep the conversation going, even if we make a decision.

I'm probably with you on either of those, I will hold my vote for now, but should be around to put a real vote in after 8 tonight.

[Hockeyguy15]

Vote Count:
Votes Hockeyguy(1): agulati
Votes Sebc(2): DropIt, mrkajz44
Votes Scornfire(2): crazy_eoj, WinnipegFan,
Votes crazy_eoj(2): Scornfire, SebC
Votes mrkajz44(1): Puxlut

Hasn’t Voted (3):
Hockeyguy15, Fuzz, devo22

The more I look at this the more I lean towards crazy_eoj. Originally I was looking at it as GGG with two new players and one of them voting Bonded (leaving DropIt and Scornfire). Some good points have been made about eoj though. I'm not 100% decided yet but I can be put down for a soft eoj vote at the moment.

[Scornfire]

Originally Posted by crazy_eoj

This post becomes very interesting based on where we are at right now? Bonded's last post before being lynched.

Of course the very next post after that night period ended was Scorn jumping out with an accusation against me that he built on bad information.

I'll reiterate *again* that I corrected that statement 8m after I posted it. I've addressed why I felt Bonded said that about me several times