Who was the dirtiest Flame?

[N-E-B]

Originally Posted by dino7c

Oh sweet summer child, Tkachuk's worst incidents happened every game back in the day. Guy hasn't been suspended in three seasons in this pansy ass league these days. What is the worst thing Tkachuk has done? throw and elbow lol.

Tkachuk’s reputation as a dirty player is completely fabricated by the media and morons who don’t ever watch him. They think that because you’re a pest it must mean you’re dirty and out for blood.

Tkachuk is a pest, but dirty? No. There’s a difference.

[Eric Vail]

Tim Hunter was no choir boy.

[Geeoff]

Originally Posted by Magnum PEI

Tkachuk is the dirtiest flame I've seen by a longshot.
Gauthier had a few dirty hits. I only recall one Marchment incident while he was here. Giordano has a reputation, but I don't think he's dirty at all.

IMO Tkachuk has a big mouth but isn't really that dirty. At least in terms of intent to injure stuff. For example, Scheifele in the play-ins was just a fluke injury and yet people from other teams will definitely added it to his list because Matthew gets under their skin.

[Nage Waza]

Originally Posted by Eric Vail

Tim Hunter was no choir boy.

I was at this game in a box with Jets players. I was told before the game I couldn't cheer for the Flames.