CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[kermitology]

Now that there's a bit of logic and reason going on here with the death of our townie friend Timbo.

Unvote

[CaptainCrunch]

Wow, I was typing my response when the night move came up, Timbo being town was surprising. I also think I was wrong on an assumption, because this thread was happening so fast, I thought GGG threw himself in front of the vig, I don't think that's the case.

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by GGG

I never offered myself as the VIG target. That was Rathji, I campaigned for the real vig to kill the fake vig

Yeah, I corrected that, sorry for the confusion

[starseed]

I think our best move at this point is to get ineedanother to pick our next target. If you have to leave, then just vote with your instinct at this point.

[CaptainCrunch]

That's an interesting suggestion.

[hmmhmmcamo]

Originally Posted by GGG

So of the pile ons mmmcamo to be is the most suspicious, it provides justification, but the logic in it is badly flawed. The bolded section above he just dismisses the sound logic of how to deal with the situation without providing a reason. The first line trys to justfies inactivity.

I would like to hear from mmmcamo why he thought the wait and see approach was nonsense.

The other interesting pileon was transplant99 who just voted with no justification. I perfer to vote for these two over kermit.

There were calls for the “real” vigilante to kill ineedanother immediately, and that if a kill didn’t happen right away it would prove ineedanother was telling the truth. I thought it was a stretch to make that conclusion because a) some players haven’t been around/posted much and b) this game has lots of first time players and the “real” vigilante might hesitate /not know what the right thing to do is/keep quiet.

If I was the “real” vigilante, I would be pretty hesitant to role reveal myself this early after all the ridicule ineedanother took after making his claim.

I just thought the way ineedanother revealed himself was strange, and that he was acting more “what’s best for ineedanother” instead of “what’s best for the Town”. Clearly I was wrong


Unvote

[Hockeyguy15]

Just want to put this out there for day 2 incase I am night killed.

We may want to look at inactivity next as vote criteria, I know it isn't popular but hear me out. There are 2 mafia factions this time around, so mafia is going to be worried about lynching and getting night killed by the other faction. So what I believe would be their best hope now that we are running around killing our own is to fade into the background.

Now back to today. However we want to vote is fine with me, I will leave my vote on kermit until we have a plan of attack.

[Kjesse]

Yes two mafia groups means there is a fog of war for each of them, so to speak, where they don't know who the others are. We're not looking for a singular group of 8 mafia working together, the most than can be said is the mafia is working in smaller groups of 4. This makes it harder to make determinations based on voting history.

[ineedanother]

Crap, I thought I had it right with Timbo. Guess I will have to venture a different direction now. I am going to place my vote now as I have a golf game this afternoon so won't be able to post much during that time. If somebody doesn't get lynched before I am back I will post some other thoughts.

Vote: hmmhmmcamo

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Just want to put this out there for day 2 incase I am night killed.

We may want to look at inactivity next as vote criteria, I know it isn't popular but hear me out. There are 2 mafia factions this time around, so mafia is going to be worried about lynching and getting night killed by the other faction. So what I believe would be their best hope now that we are running around killing our own is to fade into the background.

Now back to today. However we want to vote is fine with me, I will leave my vote on kermit until we have a plan of attack.

with the chaos today, they haven't had to do much, they can sit in the background while the vig is forced down and a townie is blasted in the face and they have a sure townie in their pocket now.

Over all this is pretty much a win day for the mob already. With two night kills and a lynching it could be a very good day if we're not really careful in our vote, and in who we beg the doc to block..

[Street Pharmacist]

Not a great excuse for inactivity, but I'm dealing with an armed robbery at work and have been extremely busy. I'll catch up soon

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

Not a great excuse for inactivity, but I'm dealing with an armed robbery at work and have been extremely busy. I'll catch up soon

Just hand over your wallet and tell the guy that you're falling behind in the game. Then shoot him in the face with mace

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

Not a great excuse for inactivity, but I'm dealing with an armed robbery at work and have been extremely busy. I'll catch up soon

Sounds like the short of activity Mafia would do............




Serious note, hope everything/everyone is Ok/safe.

[GGG]

vote transplant99

He was part of the run on ineedanother and was inactive prior. I find mmmcamos response for his decision yesterday believable.

If general if we lynch another player today then looking at someone who didnt get involved in the vigilante discussion would be a good place to start.

[Street Pharmacist]

I'm not convinced on anyone and have a problem feeling sorry for people getting lynched so early, but someone has to. I'll follow the highest vote count. Who's in the lead right now?

[GGG]

Kermit, I think has the most votes right now but thats based on feeling and not a hard count.

[devo22]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

I'm not convinced on anyone and have a problem feeling sorry for people getting lynched so early, but someone has to. I'll follow the highest vote count. Who's in the lead right now?

just flipped through the pages:

ineedanother (3): Rathji, Street Pharmacist, transplant99
kermitology (3): HockeyGuy15, strombad, DropIt
hmmhmmcamo (2): dsavillian, ineedanother
Completely (1): Lego Man
transplant99 (1): GGG
Crazy Bacon Legs (1): Oling_Roachinen

hope I didn't overlook any votes or unvotes, but yeah, that's roughly how things are right now.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by devo22

just flipped through the pages:

ineedanother (3): Rathji, Street Pharmacist, transplant99
kermitology (3): HockeyGuy15, strombad, DropIt
hmmhmmcamo (2): dsavillian, ineedanother
Completely (1): Lego Man
transplant99 (1): GGG
Crazy Bacon Legs (1): Oling_Roachinen

hope I didn't overlook any votes or unvotes, but yeah, that's roughly how things are right now.

So we accept/know that ineedanother is a townie.

Perhaps we should follow his lead on hmmhmmcamo.

[Hockeyguy15]

I'm a soft vote on kermit, even though I am still suspicious of him. Just waiting until we come up with a plan of attack and I will be switching my vote if needed.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 30 alive, it takes 16 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 10 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (17): flameswin, CofR, starseed, agulati, Baxter Renegade, undercoverbrother, GP_Matt, activeStick, Delgar, Aeneas, Completely, bizaro86, CaptainCrunch, devo22, HalifaxDrunk, kermitology, hmmhmmcamo

Voting:
ineedanother (3): Rathji, Street Pharmacist, transplant99
kermitology (3): strombad, Hockeyguy15, DropIt
Crazy Bacon Legs (1): Oling_Roachinen
GP_Matt (1): dsavillian
Completely (1): Lego Man
Oling_Roachinen (1): Crazy Bacon Legs
hmmhmmcamo (1): ineedanother
transplant99 (1): GGG

Deadline is Sunday, May 4th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.