I think the lumberjack is cheesy. The vintage one is pretty cool.
The problem is the Canucks shoulder patches (3rd logo) is based on this silly Johnny Canuck cartoon:
It's too bad this fan made one was never used as the Johnny Canuck character was actually a WWII pilot I think (and not a cliche lumberjack)
Then again, I'm all for the Canucks having stupid ugly things on their jerseys and masks so maybe that's a good thing.