List your top 10 NFL Quarterbacks!

[OILFAN #81]

Originally Posted by Papi34

Anyone who puts Manning ahead of Brady is just nuts. End of discussion 3 superbowl rings takes care of that argument.

And for people who want to argue, look at the weapons that manning has had his entire career.

Bradys best reciever up until 2007 (moss) was Branch. Hows Branch makin out in Seattle? Last I heard hes a boarderline camp cut!

Case closed.

So judging by your first comment why do you have Manning ahead of Roethlisberger? Ben has already won 2 Superbowl's and is in his mid 20's! Pretty weak argument.

Whichever player people put at #1 (Manning or Brady), doesn't mean the other one sucks or anything. OMG xxxxx is #2..........that's an outcry! LOLZZZZZZZ!

Both these guys are great quarterbacks.

You also forgot to mention that Peyton Manning is:

1. The only quarterback to lead his team to 6 straight 12 win seasons (NFL record and an active streak heading into this season).

2. Is the current and a 3 time NFL MVP (NFL record shared with Brett Favre). Brady has won 1 MVP award.

3. Is already 4th ALL TIME in passing TD's (will be #1 before his career finishes).

4. Is already 7th ALL TIME in passing yards (will be #1 before his career finishes).

5. Is already 5th ALL TIME in passing completions (will be top 2 before his career finishes).

6. A 10 time Pro Bowler in 12 full seasons (Brady has been a 4 time pro bowler in his 7 full seasons).


Tom Brady doesn't rank in the top 20 in any of those categories (of course he hasn't played in as many games so let's project where he would be):

Brady has played 113 Games to Manning's 176 so:

Passing Yards

Manning at 176 games is at 45628 passing yards.

Brady (currently at 26446 passing yards in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 41190.

Touchdowns:

Manning at 176 games is at 333 TD's.

Brady (currently at 197 TD's in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 307 TD's.

Completions:

Manning at 176 games has 3839 completions.

Brady (currently at 2301 completions in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 3584 completions.

Manning is on pace to be #1 in Touchdowns, Yards and Completions all time. Pretty hard to ignore that.

I wanted to bold the most important part:

With these numbers i'm not suggesting Brady sucks or Brady is a chump. The guy has 3 Superbowls as you mentioned and is a fantastic quarterback. But for you to say that people are nuts if they pick Manning over Brady is a ridiculous statement(as it would be if people said the opposite). The guys are close. Either could be #1 or #2.

[troutman]

My all-time favorite NFL QBs:

1) Steve Grogan
2) Tom Brady
3) Dan Fouts
4) Brian Sipe
5) Joe Montana
6) Jim Zorn
7) Ken Stabler
8) Ken Anderson
9) Archie Manning
10) Steve Bartkowski

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_QB_...ds_as_starters

[burn_baby_burn]

Originally Posted by troutman

My all-time favorite NFL QBs:

1) Steve Grogan
2) Tom Brady
3) Dan Fouts
4) Brian Sipe
5) Joe Montana
6) Jim Zorn
7) Ken Stabler
8) Ken Anderson
9) Archie Manning
10) Steve Bartkowski

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NFL_QB_...ds_as_starters

What the hell??????? You forgot Otto Graham Browns fan.

[burn_baby_burn]

Originally Posted by OILFAN #81

So judging by your first comment why do you have Manning ahead of Roethlisberger? Ben has already won 2 Superbowl's and is in his mid 20's! Pretty weak argument.

Whichever player people put at #1 (Manning or Brady), doesn't mean the other one sucks or anything. OMG xxxxx is #2..........that's an outcry! LOLZZZZZZZ!

Both these guys are great quarterbacks.

You also forgot to mention that Peyton Manning is:

1. The only quarterback to lead his team to 6 straight 12 win seasons (NFL record and an active streak heading into this season).

2. Is the current and a 3 time NFL MVP (NFL record shared with Brett Favre). Brady has won 1 MVP award.

3. Is already 4th ALL TIME in passing TD's (will be #1 before his career finishes).

4. Is already 7th ALL TIME in passing yards (will be #1 before his career finishes).

5. Is already 5th ALL TIME in passing completions (will be top 2 before his career finishes).

6. A 10 time Pro Bowler in 12 full seasons (Brady has been a 4 time pro bowler in his 7 full seasons).


Tom Brady doesn't rank in the top 20 in any of those categories (of course he hasn't played in as many games so let's project where he would be):

Brady has played 113 Games to Manning's 176 so:

Passing Yards

Manning at 176 games is at 45628 passing yards.

Brady (currently at 26446 passing yards in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 41190.

Touchdowns:

Manning at 176 games is at 333 TD's.

Brady (currently at 197 TD's in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 307 TD's.

Completions:

Manning at 176 games has 3839 completions.

Brady (currently at 2301 completions in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 3584 completions.

Manning is on pace to be #1 in Touchdowns, Yards and Completions all time. Pretty hard to ignore that.

I wanted to bold the most important part:

With these numbers i'm not suggesting Brady sucks or Brady is a chump. The guy has 3 Superbowls as you mentioned and is a fantastic quarterback. But for you to say that people are nuts if they pick Manning over Brady is a ridiculous statement(as it would be if people said the opposite). The guys are close. Either could be #1 or #2.

Real close. Peyton Manning career QB rating of 94.8. Tom Brady career QB rating of 92.9.

[Saint Troy]

1.Brees
2.Manning
3.Brady
4.Rivers
5.Rodgers
6.Roethlisberger
7.Cutler
8.McNabb
9.Eli
10.Ryan

[Displaced Flames fan]

Sweet...I'll do my 10 all-time favorites too! Great idea Trouty! I will only use QB's I watched.

1. John Elway
2. Dan Fouts
3. Jim Zorn
4. Brett Favre
5. Warren Moon
6. Dave Krieg
7. Randall Cunningham
8. Jake Plummer
9. Steve Bartkowski
10. Kordell Stewart

[troutman]

Originally Posted by burn_baby_burn

What the hell??????? You forgot Otto Graham Browns fan.

I'm not that old!

[troutman]

Originally Posted by burn_baby_burn

Real close. Peyton Manning career QB rating of 94.8. Tom Brady career QB rating of 92.9.

That's a good indicator, but it only shows how well a QB passes the ball. They have to do lots of other things too - run, hand-off, manage the clock, read defences, run an offence, lead etc.

[zukes]

1. Brady
2. P.Manning
3. Brees
4. Rivers
5. Rodgers
6. Roethlisberger
7. Palmer
8. Cutler
9. Ryan
10. Romo

Warner and Flacco would be next.

[Papi34]

Originally Posted by OILFAN #81

So judging by your first comment why do you have Manning ahead of Roethlisberger? Ben has already won 2 Superbowl's and is in his mid 20's! Pretty weak argument.

Whichever player people put at #1 (Manning or Brady), doesn't mean the other one sucks or anything. OMG xxxxx is #2..........that's an outcry! LOLZZZZZZZ!

Both these guys are great quarterbacks.

You also forgot to mention that Peyton Manning is:

1. The only quarterback to lead his team to 6 straight 12 win seasons (NFL record and an active streak heading into this season).

2. Is the current and a 3 time NFL MVP (NFL record shared with Brett Favre). Brady has won 1 MVP award.

3. Is already 4th ALL TIME in passing TD's (will be #1 before his career finishes).

4. Is already 7th ALL TIME in passing yards (will be #1 before his career finishes).

5. Is already 5th ALL TIME in passing completions (will be top 2 before his career finishes).

6. A 10 time Pro Bowler in 12 full seasons (Brady has been a 4 time pro bowler in his 7 full seasons).


Tom Brady doesn't rank in the top 20 in any of those categories (of course he hasn't played in as many games so let's project where he would be):

Brady has played 113 Games to Manning's 176 so:

Passing Yards

Manning at 176 games is at 45628 passing yards.

Brady (currently at 26446 passing yards in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 41190.

Touchdowns:

Manning at 176 games is at 333 TD's.

Brady (currently at 197 TD's in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 307 TD's.

Completions:

Manning at 176 games has 3839 completions.

Brady (currently at 2301 completions in 113 games) at 176 games would be projected to be at 3584 completions.

Manning is on pace to be #1 in Touchdowns, Yards and Completions all time. Pretty hard to ignore that.

I wanted to bold the most important part:

With these numbers i'm not suggesting Brady sucks or Brady is a chump. The guy has 3 Superbowls as you mentioned and is a fantastic quarterback. But for you to say that people are nuts if they pick Manning over Brady is a ridiculous statement(as it would be if people said the opposite). The guys are close. Either could be #1 or #2.

Well ill be damned! what a counter argument i love these talks. Its very hard to compare the two based soley on offensive numbers because as stated before the offensive weapons that Manning has always had. I think we can agree that Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne were much much better than anything the Pats had at WR ie Deion Branch, David Givens and the latter years of Troy Brown.

Offensively you would have to expect Manning to have far superior numbers based soley on personell surrounding him.

However, I do agree that the Pats three championships were won primarilly on Defense something that was far superior to the colts in that day and age. Surely without the strong D NE probably wouldnt be sitting with three rings.

I think my post was taken as a pure diss on Manning which couldnt be more wrong because ive never seen a QB with the ability to sling one deep mid or short in the perfect place for his reciever. My point was simply he has had better weapons on the OFFENSIVE side i think everyone can agree with that.
We also saw what TB12 is capable of with a superstar rcv (Moss) in the one year and 8 plays hes been able to play with him. Should be an interesting season to see if they can come back to that form

Thanks for this topic tho oilfan im so dam excited for this season to start enough of the pre season!!!

one last thing

Go pats!

[rubecube]

Top 10 All-time that I had a chance to watch (basically 1991-present)

1. Tom Brady - New England Patriots
2. Steve Young - San Francisco 49ers
3. Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts
4. John Elway - Denver Broncos
5. Brett Favre - Green Bay Packers
6. Dan Marino - Miami Dolphins
7. Troy Aikman - Dallas Cowboys (puke)
8. Kurt Warner -St. Louis Rams/Arizona Cardinals
9. Donovan McNabb - Philadelphia Eagles
10. Joe Montana - Kansas City Chiefs

[mykalberta]

1 Brady
2 Manning
3 Brees
4 Rodgers
5 McNabb
6 Rivers
7 Palmer
8 Cutler
9 Warrner
10 Romo/Ryan

[iggnuef]

Why is Tony "choke" Romo even in people's top 15?????? Let's see how he does this year without TO....no playoffs for the 'Boys this year!!

[mykalberta]

Originally Posted by iggnuef

Why is Tony "choke" Romo even in people's top 15?????? Let's see how he does this year without TO....no playoffs for the 'Boys this year!!

So I assume you can mention 15 QB better than him?

[iggnuef]

Originally Posted by mykalberta

So I assume you can mention 15 QB better than him?

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. Favre
4. Big Ben
5. Brees
6. McNabb
7. Warrner
8. Palmer
9. Cutler
10. Rivers
11. Ryan
12. E. Manning
13. Flacco
14. Delhome
15. Hasselback

I would take anyone of these QB's over Romo!! IMO he is the single most overrated PLAYER in the NFL!! If he wasn't playing for "America's Team" and didn't get the TV exposure we wouldn't hear much about T.Homo.

[mykalberta]

Flacco, Delhomme, Favre - hahahahaha.