Flames player fan poll (August 2023)

[FBI]

Now you gotta take em all and put em in a spreadsheet and get the averages. I did this many years ago too heh

[FBI]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 6
- Nazem Kadri 5
- Jacob Markstrom 5
- Rasmus Andersson 7
- Mackenzie Weegar 7
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury 5
- Johnny Gaudreau 4
- Matthew Tkachuk 4

[Red_Baron]

Jonathan Huberdeau 4
- Nazem Kadri 5
- Jacob Markstrom 4
- Rasmus Andersson 7
- Mackenzie Weegar 8
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury 7
- Johnny Gaudreau 9
- Matthew Tkachuk 9

[midniteowl]

- Jonathan Huberdeau -- 8
- Nazem Kadri -- 7
- Jacob Markstrom -- 8
- Rasmus Andersson -- 7
- Mackenzie Weegar -- 7
- Lanny McDonald -- 8
- Theo Fleury -- 8
- Johnny Gaudreau -- 5
- Matthew Tkachuk -- 5
- Jarome Iginla -- 10
- Gary Roberts -- 10

[Nammer403]

Jonathan Huberdeau 8
- Nazem Kadri 6
- Jacob Markstrom 5
- Rasmus Andersson 9
- Mackenzie Weegar 9
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury - 1
- Johnny Gaudreau - 7
- Matthew Tkachuk - 8
- Robyn Regher - 10

[Flamesfan05]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 7
- Nazem Kadri 1
- Jacob Markstrom 3
- Rasmus Andersson 7
- Mackenzie Weegar 5
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury 10
- Johnny Gaudreau 10
- Matthew Tkachuk 10

[Reign of Fire]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 7
- Nazem Kadri - 5
- Jacob Markstrom - 5
- Rasmus Andersson - 8
- Mackenzie Weegar - 6
- Lanny McDonald - 10
- Theo Fleury - 10
- Johnny Gaudreau - 10
- Matthew Tkachuk - 9
- Iginla - 10
- Kipper - 10

[activeStick]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 8
- Nazem Kadri - 8
- Jacob Markstrom - 8
- Rasmus Andersson - 10
- Mackenzie Weegar - 9
- Lanny McDonald - 10
- Theo Fleury - 10 (purely based on assessment as a hockey player, like everyone else above)
- Johnny Gaudreau - 10
- Matthew Tkachuk - 10
- Nikita Zadorov - 9 (you choose the player)

[Cycling76er]

-Theo Fleury - Human filth. Unsure how to assign a numeric value to that.

[gilligans_off]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 5
- Nazem Kadri 2
- Jacob Markstrom 5
- Rasmus Andersson 7
- Mackenzie Weegar 6
- Lanny McDonald 8
- Theo Fleury 9
- Johnny Gaudreau 7
- Matthew Tkachuk 7
- Jarome Iginla 10
- Kipper & Regher 9
- Fred Brathwaite 8

[Stillman16]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 8
- Nazem Kadri 6
- Jacob Markstrom 7
- Rasmus Andersson 9
- Mackenzie Weegar 9
- Lanny McDonald 9
- Theo Fleury 10 (player) 0 (role model)
- Johnny Gaudreau 9
- Matthew Tkachuk 9
- Cory Stillman 16 (you choose the player)

[JBR]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 8
- Nazem Kadri - 6
- Jacob Markstrom - 6
- Rasmus Andersson - 7
- Mackenzie Weegar - 9
- Lanny McDonald - 10
- Theo Fleury - 2 (playing career with Flames only)
- Johnny Gaudreau - Flames 9, other 0
- Matthew Tkachuk - 6
- Kipper - 10
- Joe Nieuwendyk - 9
- Brad McCrimmon - 10

[SeanCharles]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 6
- Nazem Kadri - 2
- Jacob Markstrom - 5
- Rasmus Andersson - 9
- Mackenzie Weegar - 8
- Lanny McDonald - 7
- Theo Fleury - 8
- Johnny Gaudreau - 5
- Matthew Tkachuk - 6

[mile]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 8
- Nazem Kadri - 8
- Jacob Markstrom - 7
- Rasmus Andersson - 9
- Mackenzie Weegar - 9
- Lanny McDonald - 9
- Theo Fleury - 2
- Johnny Gaudreau - 4
- Matthew Tkachuk - 3
- Dan Vladar - 9

[taxbuster]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 6 (mostly for being good to Pelts)
- Nazem Kadri - 4
- Jacob Markstrom - 0>9 depending on the game
- Rasmus Andersson - 7
- Mackenzie Weegar - 7
- Lanny McDonald - 9
- Theo Fleury - 9 while playing for us, 5 because the poor bastard got a raw deal in life (yah, I know...still have to do what you can etc.)
- Johnny Gaudreau - 9
- Matthew Tkachuk - 9 on the days when he GAF, 0 the days he didn't
- Jarome - 888, because he always GAF
- Miikka - 887, for the thousand mile stare
- Regehr - 886, just for crushing Hemsky so often

Edit: for Theo it has nothing to do with Politics for me...I think he played his best hockey for us and loved him for it...and I think he played poorer hockey when he left. Period.

[Jiri Hrdina]

- Jonathan Huberdeau: 7
- Nazem Kadri: 8
- Jacob Markstrom: 7
- Rasmus Andersson: 9
- Mackenzie Weegar: 9
- Lanny McDonald: 7
- Theo Fleury: 0
- Johnny Gaudreau: 5
- Matthew Tkachuk: 6
- Hrdina: 100

[Finger Cookin]

Originally Posted by tvp2003

I was curious what the temperature is regarding individual players on this team (current and former), so I thought I'd post a super-scientific poll with the simple question:

On a scale of 1 to 10, how much of a fan are you of ________.

I don't want to make it too technical or complicated; either you love them (9 or 10), hate them (1 or 2), or somewhere in between:

- Jonathan Huberdeau
- Nazem Kadri
- Jacob Markstrom
- Rasmus Andersson
- Mackenzie Weegar
- Lanny McDonald
- Theo Fleury
- Johnny Gaudreau
- Matthew Tkachuk
- _____________ (you choose the player)

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 5
- Nazem Kadri - 4
- Jacob Markstrom - 6
- Rasmus Andersson - 7
- Mackenzie Weegar - 6
- Lanny McDonald - 8
- Theo Fleury - 2
- Johnny Gaudreau - 8
- Matthew Tkachuk - 6
- Jarome Iginla - 12

[FireItUp]

Originally Posted by KootenayFlamesFan

When Theo was playing he was a 10 for me. Now, it's 0. Sad downfall.

There are only 2 reasons why Flames fans aren't giving Theo a decent rating...

1) You never really liked him as a player.
2) You usually vote either NDP or Liberal and dislike those who have different political views.

Judging by your comment...we know why you gave him a 0.

[Displaced Flames fan]

Jonathan Huberdeau - 6
- Nazem Kadri - 5
- Jacob Markstrom - 6
- Rasmus Andersson - 9
- Mackenzie Weegar - 8
- Lanny McDonald - 10
- Theo Fleury - 2
- Johnny Gaudreau - 6
- Matthew Tkachuk - 7
-Mikael Backlund - 10
Dustin Wolf-32

[Jiri Hrdina]

Originally Posted by FireItUp

There are only 2 reasons why Flames fans aren't giving Theo a decent rating...

1) You never really liked him as a player.
2) You usually vote either NDP or Liberal and dislike those who have different political views.

Judging by your comment...we know why you gave him a 0.

3) He's someone that has treated people poorly for a very long time, slammed the organization that gave him several chances, and spreads dangerous falsehoods.


I have voted for NDP, Liberal and PC over the years. The world is not as binary as you seem to think it is.