All time Jays: Catcher

[Enoch Root]

Jays have never had a dominant catcher.

[Hockey]

Voted Borders, but only because JP Arencibia wasn't an option.

[BloodFetish]

I remember a game down the I5 in Seattle. The Mariners were up 10-0, but the Blue Jays came back to win it 11-10, capped by a home run off the bat of Ernie Whitt. I think it was a grand salami, too!

Whitt was a beauty.

[Mister Yamoto]

Greg Zaun takes the sharpest dressed category.

[Galakanokis]

Big fan of Whitt but I love me some Borders. He was/is one of my all time favorites. He'd be all dirty with that wad of chew in his mouth.

He's coaching somewhere now.

[Cali Panthers Fan]

Originally Posted by Mister Yamoto

Greg Zaun takes the sharpest dressed category.

One man agrees

Spoiler!

[JiriHrdina]

Closing it down.
Ernie Whitt is your starter, backed up by Pat Borders.

[Derek Sutton]

Too late to vote for Buck. Really the catchers are all pretty weak, so I vote Buck because of A) the broken leg dp, B) he was a (lousy) manger, C) his work as an analyst D) his work as pbp guy. He also loves the Jays. Ernie Whitt is a good pick though and Pat Borders is a career back up so it is a good tandem.

[OzSome]

Looks like I can't vote anymore but my pick is Buck Martinez.

[zukes]

Once again, the current catcher is the most talented catcher the Jays have ever had. I would have voted Martin 1, Whitt 2

[JiriHrdina]

People can choose to answers as they wish, but I wouldn't vote on the basis of "most talented'. For me tenure has to be a part of the equation.

[browna]

Too late for the poll...but Buck did it all.
Commentator, manager, color commentator, and catcher...credited with 2 put outs, 1 with a broken leg against the M's in the Kingdome.

[Party Elephant]

Originally Posted by browna

Too late for the poll...but Buck did it all.
Commentator, manager, color commentator, and catcher...credited with 2 put outs, 1 with a broken leg against the M's in the Kingdome.

lol at the 3 shots of the same fans reacting to that play.