Flames players popularity

[bc-chris]

for me it's fairly easy...

have they ever played for the canucks or oilers....

no - then 10
yes - most likely not higher than 5 or 6, except for glencross... he's been free of the stink long enough that he'd be a 10

[RyZ]

G
Ramo 8
Hiller 7
Ortio 8
Gillies 7

D
Giordano 9
Brodie 8
Wideman 6
Russell 6
Engelland 6
Wotherspoon 7
Smid 6


C
Monahan 9
Backlund 8
Stajan 6
Bennett 9
Knight 6
Jankowski 7


Wings:
Glencross 7
Hudler 7
Byron 3
Jones 3
Bouma 8
Baertschi 9
Granlund 7
Reinhart 8
Colborne 7
Bollig 7
Mcgrattan 8
Raymond 7
Gaudreau 9

Management:
Hartley 7
Burke 9

[FBI]

Forgot klimchuk and poirier some of my favorite prospects, added them in.

[ToraToraTora]

I think we need hockey to start again.

[4oh3]

G


Ramo 7


Hiller 8


Ortio 6


Gillies 6


McDonald 6





D


Giordano 10


Brodie 10


Wideman 3


Russell 7


Engelland 6


Sieloff 8


Wotherspoon 7


Smid 8


Kanzig 7





C


Monahan 10


Backlund 10


Stajan 7


Bennett 9


Knight 8


Jankowski 4


Arnold 6





Wings:


Glencross 5


Hudler 7


Byron 8


Jones 1


Bouma 10


Baertschi 6


Granlund 6


Reinhart 8


Colborne 8


Bollig 6


Mcgrattan 10,000,000


Raymond 4


Gaudreau 10





Management:


Hartley 9


Burke 10

[kn]

G
Ramo 5
Hiller 5
Ortio 8
Gillies 6
McDonald 3

D
Giordano 9
Brodie 8
Wideman 3
Russell 3
Engelland ?
Sieloff 10
Wotherspoon 7
Smid 5
Kanzig 8

C
Monahan 10
Backlund 7
Stajan 5
Bennett 7
Knight 4
Jankowski 3
Arnold 6

Wings:
Glencross 5
Hudler 5
Byron 4
Jones 1
Bouma 8
Baertschi 4
Granlund 7
Reinhart 6
Colborne 3
Bollig ?
Mcgrattan 7
Raymond 5
Gaudreau 10
Klimchuk 6
Poirier 7
Agostino 5


Management:
Hartley 7
Burke 8
Treliving 8

[squirtle]

G
Ramo 7
Hiller 8
Ortio 8
Gillies 9

D
Giordano 10
Brodie 10
Wideman 6
Russell 6
Engelland 6
Wotherspoon 9
Smid 6


C
Monahan 10
Backlund 8
Stajan 7
Bennett 10
Knight 7
Jankowski 8


Wings:
Glencross 7
Hudler 7
Byron 8
Jones 5
Bouma 10
Baertschi 8
Granlund 8
Reinhart 8
Colborne 7
Bollig 7
Mcgrattan 10
Raymond 7
Gaudreau 10

Management:
Hartley 8
Burke 9
Treliving 8

[FBI]

So after 11 votes so far, here's a few interesting ones to start: both Gio and Gaudreau averaging 9.36. David Jones is averaging 1.9

So basically what I've learned so far is everyone loves Gaudreau and everyone hates David Jones heh

[Camronius]

G
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10

D
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10


C
Monahan 8.7
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10


Wings:
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 9.9
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10

Management:
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10
Gaudreau 10

[dieHARDflameZ]

G
Ramo 7
Hiller 7
Ortio 8
Gillies 8
McDonald 5

D
Giordano 9
Brodie 8
Wideman 5
Russell 6
Engelland 6
Sieloff 7
Wotherspoon 7
Smid 6
Kanzig 5

C
Monahan 10
Backlund 9
Stajan 6
Bennett 8
Knight 4
Jankowski 5
Arnold 6

Wings:
Glencross 4
Hudler 7
Byron 6
Jones 3
Bouma 8
Baertschi 7
Granlund 7
Reinhart 6
Colborne 7
Bollig 6
Mcgrattan 8
Raymond 6
Gaudreau 9
Klimchuk 7
Poirier 7
Agostino 5


Management:
Hartley 8
Burke 7
Treliving 8

[shniper]

G
Ramo 5
Hiller 8
Ortio 7
Gillies 7
McDonald 5

D
Giordano 9
Brodie 7
Wideman 6
Russell 6
Engelland ?
Sieloff 7
Wotherspoon 7
Smid 6
Kanzig 6

C
Monahan 10
Backlund 8
Stajan 4
Bennett 9
Knight 5
Jankowski 6
Arnold 7

Wings:
Glencross 7
Hudler 10
Byron 6
Jones 3
Bouma 6
Baertschi 8
Granlund 6
Reinhart 6
Colborne 8
Bollig 5
Mcgrattan 9
Raymond 7
Gaudreau 10
Klimchuk 7
Poirier 7
Agostino 6


Management:
Hartley 8
Burke 9
Treliving 7

[savardandjokinen]

G
Ramo 8
Hiller 7
Ortio 8
Gillies 8
McDonald 5

D
Giordano 10
Brodie 10
Wideman 5
Russell 8
Engelland 3
Sieloff 8
Wotherspoon 9
Smid 7
Kanzig 4

C
Monahan 10
Backlund 9
Stajan 5
Bennett 10
Knight 8
Jankowski 8
Arnold 8
Wings:
Glencross 7
Hudler 8
Byron 6
Jones 1
Bouma 6
Baertschi 10 (I know, I have to I've met him more than 10 times)
Granlund 8
Reinhart 8
Colborne 7
Bollig 3
Mcgrattan 8
Raymond 6
Gaudreau 10
Klimchuk 8
Poirier 9
Agostino 8


Management:
Hartley 9
Burke 6
Treliving 6


Also gonna add:
Hanowski 8
Wolf 4
Van Brabant 4
Kulak 7
Culkin 7
Smith 7
Mattson 7
Rafikov 8
Elson 4
Carroll 7

[CsInMyBlood]

G
Ramo 7
Hiller 7
Ortio 7
Gillies 7
D
Giordano 10
Brodie 10
Wideman 6
Russell 7
Engelland ?
Sieloff 7
Wotherspoon 5
Smid 5
Kanzig 5

C
Monahan 8
Backlund 10
Stajan 2
Bennett 9
Knight 5
Jankowski 7
Arnold 5

Wings:
Glencross 5
Hudler 6
Byron 9
Jones 0
Bouma 8
Baertschi 10
Granlund 7
Reinhart 6
Colborne 5
Bollig ?
Mcgrattan 9
Raymond 5
Gaudreau 10
Klimchuk 7
Poirier 8
Agostino 5

Management:
Hartley 7
Burke 5
Treliving 7

[FBI]

Since I'm a big nerd, I'm going to put all these results in a spreadsheet and get the averages to see who our favorite players are..

Looks like Monahan leads the charge right now with a 9.5 rating

[spetch]

Where did all of our Brodie haters go?? All I keep seeing is 7-10's for him!

[Savvy27]

G
Ramo 7
Hiller 7
Ortio 8
Gillies 8

D
Giordano 10
Brodie 9
Wideman 3
Russell 6
Engelland ?
Sieloff 6
Wotherspoon 8
Smid 7
Kanzig 5

C
Monahan 10
Backlund 10
Stajan 6
Bennett 8
Knight 5
Jankowski 5
Arnold 5

Wings:
Glencross 6
Hudler 8
Byron 7
Jones 3
Bouma 7
Baertschi 8
Granlund 8
Reinhart 7
Colborne 8
Bollig ?
Mcgrattan 7
Raymond ?
Gaudreau 10
Klimchuk 8
Poirier 8
Agostino 5

Management:
Hartley 8
Burke 7
Treliving 7

[Aeneas]

Originally Posted by fotze

I think the Engelland rating will be Butler/Comeau.

Engelland 10

I have always liked him, thought he would be a perfect 5/6 D man for the Flames.
No time to do the whole team, but

Bouma 10
Brodie 10
Giordano 9
Backlund 9
Wotherspoon 8

Glencross 5
Hudler 5

[Hugh Jahrmes]

Originally Posted by toratoratora

i think we need hockey to start again.

10


Quick edit.. Aeneas, Hudler a 5 for popularity?

[Aeneas]

Originally Posted by Hugh Jahrmes

10


Quick edit.. Aeneas, Hudler a 5 for popularity?

Hated him when he was a Red Wing, he typified many things I dislike in a player: smallish, went down too easy, mouthy. I must suffer him as a Flame. Also a wonderful Czech CPer gave me some not so inside info. Was less than complimentary.

Only my opinion. As you can see, when Bouma is one of my favourites, a guy like Hudler may not be.

[FBI]

OK so far out of 16+ entries, here is who CP likes of our goalies:
Also wrote down users that were quite above or below the norm CP pick.

Ortio 7.44, outliers: 4oh3 - 6
Hiller 7.25, outliers: kn - 5
Gillies: 7.13, outliers: Monahan23 - 10, TraditionalAle & Hummdeedoo - 5
Ramo: 6.75, outliers: ReadOnly - 4
Mason Mcdonald: 5.29, outliers: kn - 3

So as a group so far, we aren't particularly high or low on any of our goalies (except for unproven 2nd round pick Mcdonald)
We like Ortio better than Gillies so far.

Defense next!