Quote:
Originally Posted by _Q_
Photon: You're assuming that the tungsten filament converts the same % of energy into heat as a fan. Essentially you're saying that they have identical efficiency, which isn't the case.
|
Are we worried about the efficiency of the object though? For a light bulb that's just a measure of how much energy goes to make light vs. being turned into heat right away, but for a room unless there's a window the light will bounce around until it's 100% absorbed and becomes heat anyway. Same for a fan, efficiency is just how much energy is converted to moving air vs. heat right away, and same thing eventually all the energy moving air just becomes heat. But in our case we're not worried about desired work vs heat, we're worried about where the energy eventually all goes.
Take a sealed room in a vacuum, it doesn't matter if it's a 90W light bulb or a 90W fan inside the sealed room, eventually both of those are going to be radiating 90W of energy once they've reached equilibrium aren't they? (I don't think a rotating fan is doing any work is it?)