I find the downside of large generalized (mega) threads is that, if a person doesn't keep up with what is posted, he / she may be discouraged from participating for fear they are repeating what has already been posted. Also with time, all you end up with is a majority of these types of threads.
Maybe giving a time or size limit to particular threads may provide the answer. Then once a particular thread has attained the limit and has been closed, someone would be free to start a new thread, covering the same topic...perhaps in a more specific, rather than generalized manner.
|