Lord of the Rings on Blu Ray - the proper extended edition this time

[Esoteric]

Originally Posted by Jake

Not sure if having spectacular quality is that important for these movies anymore. The graphics are pretty mediocre by todays standards IMO and blue ray doesn't help that (I own the theatrical version blue rays).

Spectacular quality improves almost everything about these movies. The initial release felt too washed out for my tastes.

I don't care how great the CGI looks, but I want to see details, colors pop, better black levels - there is a ton they can do to make these discs look better.

[Jake]

Originally Posted by Esoteric

Spectacular quality improves almost everything about these movies. The initial release felt too washed out for my tastes.

I don't care how great the CGI looks, but I want to see details, colors pop, better black levels - there is a ton they can do to make these discs look better.

I think in some scenes the high definition makes the bad CGI more noticeable.

But for the scenes with little-no CGI I agree, there is a big improvement.

[3 Justin 3]

You guys think these movies have bad CGI?

For movies which are like 6+ years old now, the CGI is pretty damn good.