CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[jayswin]

I've got a bad feeling diss investigated sallies instead and that will be our last investigation. I was hoping we could discuss that a little further yesterday, but completely was smart and new he was a dead man and that it would be smarter to kill himself ad end the day then to let us keep discussing.

[dissentowner]

I did investigate saillias and I struck out again. He is town. I am dead next night but at least it helps narrow it down a bit more. We can still win this thing guys, I have confidence in us!

[strombad]

So how many of each mafia is left? One of each?

[ineedanother]

Well that was the best case scenario. We are now up 9-2 against the mafia. So today we. It's out CaptainCrunch, then it is 8-1 and we can just go down the list of unknown members, and it is an easy win for the town.

[ineedanother]

It's should be vote in my last post.

[Lego Man]

Originally Posted by Lego Man

Let's at least stop the two kills every night, and give the town more days to lynch the last mafia member.

Vote: CaptainCrunch

Afterwards, I say we go for HalifaxDrunk. Then (in order) Hockeyguy15, Strombad, flameswin, saillias, and finally undercoverbrother.

I really do think HalifaxDrunk is the last Mafia though.

We got dis.

It seems not too much has changed after diss investigated and found saillias to be town. Remove saillias from the list above, and follow the list - it's nearly impossible for Mafia to win now. CC the timing of your reveal was puzzling to say the least.

[strombad]

So after this:

Originally Posted by dissentowner

You want a reason? Do you really want a reason? You got it. I am the cop.
Night 1 T99 scanned SP, he was obviously not mafia and was killed later on.
Night 2 he did not even bother to do an action
Night 3 he checked strombad, he is not mafia either
Night 4 I checked Rathji, he is not mafia
Night 5 I checked Lego because I was certain he was mafia but he isn't. I was trying to say I might be down with voting for him but in reality I said I would rather vote your way because I have no idea what you are and when the votes to lynch him started coming I had to try and dissuade that vote. So there it is, you know who is town now and seeing how I am suspicious that BR is not the doctor I m probably dead anyhow. So be it. Is that good enough to second guess?

There was this (which I've edited, took out the eliminated players and added in affiliations we know about):

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Sweet!



Saillias (Town)

Rathji (Town)

strombad (Town)

dissentowner (Cop)

ineedanother (Vigilante)

Lego Man (Town)
flameswin (?)
HalifaxDrunk (?)
Hockeyguy15 (?)
undercoverbrother (?)

CaptainCrunch (Mafia?)

Which in my mind, makes this list make very little sense (the order of it at least):

Originally Posted by Lego Man

Let's at least stop the two kills every night, and give the town more days to lynch the last mafia member.

Vote: CaptainCrunch

Afterwards, I say we go for HalifaxDrunk. Then (in order) Hockeyguy15, Strombad, flameswin, saillias, and finally undercoverbrother.

I really do think HalifaxDrunk is the last Mafia though.

We got dis.

Saillias and myself are both proven town, so why would you place both of us ahead of two people who are questionable?

If for whatever reason you're suspicious of us, then the list should still turn out like this:

1. CaptainCrunch

2. HalifaxDrunk
3. flameswin
4. Hockeyguy15
5. undercoverbrother

6.dissentowner
7. strombad
8. Legoman
9. Rathji
etc.

Voting out CC is obvious. The next four (2-5) are interchangeable really, but need to go next. After that (which would only be necessary if dissentowner is not actually the cop) he goes next, and you can pick off the rest interchangeably. Otherwise, if dissentowner is telling the truth (as we all currently assume) then getting rid of anyone before the first five listed is pretty much ridiculous.

Trying to target myself or saillias before the unknowns are out just puts a target on your back, considering you were proven town the same way we were.

Vote: CaptainCrunch

[Hockeyguy15]

Let's get rid of CC and get down to one night kill. If you guys lynch me after then whatever I won't fight it.

Vote: CaptainCrunch

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by flameswin

So if I'm looking at our remaining posters for the last parker, I'm thinking like this. Correct me if I'm wrong on anything.

saillias, too much going on with kermitology, not likely

Rathji, proven town

Hockeyguy15, tough read, as he's playing like last game; Lots of posts, throwing accusations all over the place.

strombad, has posted oddly at times, but it wouldn't blow me away if he was the last parker, Has posted much more like a lone wolf than someone who is working with others behind the scenes, though, so probably town

flameswin, I know I'm town, but can understand if there's some suspicion

dissentowner, cop

ineedanother, proven town

HalifaxDrunk, my number one suspect by a country mile after reviewing his posts again

Lego Man, proven town

undercoverbrother, very un-mafia like all game

CaptainCrunch proven barrow, lame duck

We already know Strombad is town.

My list goes as follows for the last Parker.
Flameswin
HD
UCB

But if we lynch CC and he is the last barrow, we get down to one night kill. If you guys think I am mafia after that then fine, lynch me. We will win if we get this down to one night kill.

[strombad]

So, this is pretty much how the last few nights would go if we're unlucky and don't hit mafia until the end of "the list."

Night 7:
Lynch - Captain Crunch (mafia)
Kill - dissentowner (town)

Night 8:
Lynch - flameswin (town)
Kill - Legoman (town)

Night 9:
Lynch - HD (town)
Kill - ineedanother (town)

Night 10:
Lynch - UCB (town)
Kill - strombad (town)

Night 11:
Lynch - Hockeyguy15 (mafia)

Remaining town:
saillias, Rathji (2)


Thus, even in the worst case scenario, it's mathematically impossible for the town to lose if they go off the current list of knowns vs. unknowns.

Seems like good odds to me.

[undercoverbrother]

Just quick note while on my phone.

I believe that Captain Crunch is the obvious kill. Then we are down to one scum to find. We have the numbers.

vote Captain crunch

[ineedanother]

Vote: CaptainCrunch

[Rathji]

Vote: CaptainCrunch

I haven't been on a PC to actually review options for the next days vote, but now that CC is alone, he is a no brainer to lynch.

We have a while before the hammer will fall, so everyone should at least make a case for who they think is the next best vote, so when we lose them to a night kill at least we have their thoughts.

[Rathji]

I have to say that us lynching completly last night knowing that CC was mafia was a bad plan. I was not around for that entire duration, but if we had been wrong it would have been game over for us.

Killing CC would have eliminated his ability to communicate with Parker, which should have both end of us, but the remaining Parker mafia member screwing up saved us from that minor slip-up

[dissentowner]

Vote: CaptainCrunch

[saillias]

lol, that's 8 votes. we're beating up his corpse at this point. Shortest day in CP mafia history?

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by saillias

lol, that's 8 votes. we're beating up his corpse at this point. Shortest day in CP mafia history?

24 hour minimum day length, I think the day we lynched agulati was also 24 hours.

That means the hammer will fall at 8:18pm tonight.

[jayswin]

Looks like I'm near if not at the top of list for last Parker lol. All good at this point as we really can't lose this thing with all of the proven town. So obviously I won't fight it, but I would suggest that halifaxdrunk is almost assuredly going to be the guy, so might as well go for him next, and we should have this at the conclusion of day 8.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 4 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (3): saillias, HalifaxDrunk, CaptainCrunch

Voting:
CaptainCrunch (8): Lego Man, flameswin, strombad, Hockeyguy15, undercoverbrother, ineedanother, Rathji, dissentowner

Deadline is Thursday, May 29th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time. Hammer cannot be dropped before Sunday, May 25th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[saillias]

Well that's good, gives us time to think about tomorrow's guy. I also think it's going to be HalifaxDrunk. However I find that whatever my instinct has been in this game, the truth is the complete opposite

vote: Captain Crunch