CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[agulati]

Or we get to the next page!

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by agulati

Or we get to the next page!

Seems to me that only mafia would be so rude and uncaring of fellow town people..

[Timbo]

I really hope Hockeyguy15 is a townie like I said before he would be a great asset.

But having said that I am not sure where any one is aligned .
I even have considered HG15, Strombad are together and Then Delgar jumps in and basically steers the boat away from HG15,a friggin dream team of mafia as they post alot
And steer with authority.
But really It's all just guess work right now.

[Hockeyguy15]

Here is where I am at...

Strombad and CC voted for me, now out of the two of them the only thing that stuck out to me was that CC commented early on about mafia strategy. At the moment I tend to believe that both are townies, but I could be wrong and it was a failed attempt at getting votes rolling my way.

Timbo, Delgar, Devo, Aeneas, DropIt, Bizaro all 'defended' me I guess you could say. Now being a vocal player I don't feel like it would be in the mafia's best interest to defend me. If anything it would have been best for them to kind of let the vote against me happen naturally so they can stay out of the spot light.

hmmhmmcamo said vote Timbo and if he is mafia, vote for me. Timbo was early to be weary of voting for me so I don't believe he is mafia at this time.

HD did that thing where he looks like he is giving insight but he kind of just sits on the fence. This seems to me like something mafia would do, because it makes it look like they are engaged but they really don't offer up anything new. He also seems to mention mafia a lot in his posts.

SP got kind of defensive when I called him out.

[HalifaxDrunk]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Do you have a theory to back this up, or is it just a random finger point?

Just looks like he is trying to throw suspicion elsewhere as if there is inside knowledge of your role. I agree looking elsewhere is important but saying "that's enough attention on hockeyguy for now." got my spidey sense tingling. Smells like working the Mafia buddy system.

[jayswin]

Personally, I dont understand how any of you are getting anything from anyone's posts at this point. It's almost all the same posters and we've all had a whole game of seeing what constitutes a suspicious post.

[HalifaxDrunk]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

HD did that thing where he looks like he is giving insight but he kind of just sits on the fence. This seems to me like something mafia would do, because it makes it look like they are engaged but they really don't offer up anything new. He also seems to mention mafia a lot in his posts.

"That thing" I do? How could I have insight, it's all speculation at this point. I pointed a finger at Delgar suspecting Mafia ties, no one else had done that before how is that not something new?

What do you mean I've mentioned Mafia a lot in my posts? We are tying to uncover the Mafia hard not to say the word.

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Here is where I am at...

Strombad and CC voted for me, now out of the two of them the only thing that stuck out to me was that CC commented early on about mafia strategy. At the moment I tend to believe that both are townies, but I could be wrong and it was a failed attempt at getting votes rolling my way.

Timbo, Delgar, Devo, Aeneas, DropIt, Bizaro all 'defended' me I guess you could say. Now being a vocal player I don't feel like it would be in the mafia's best interest to defend me. If anything it would have been best for them to kind of let the vote against me happen naturally so they can stay out of the spot light.

hmmhmmcamo said vote Timbo and if he is mafia, vote for me. Timbo was early to be weary of voting for me so I don't believe he is mafia at this time.

HD did that thing where he looks like he is giving insight but he kind of just sits on the fence. This seems to me like something mafia would do, because it makes it look like they are engaged but they really don't offer up anything new. He also seems to mention mafia a lot in his posts.

SP got kind of defensive when I called him out.

I got defensive last time too, because your throwing suspicion based on complete randomness. First day posts are meant to be random as there's no history. You can't invent history on day 1 to got a narrative and expect it to be correct. You're playing way too hard on day 1 with nothing to go on

[Street Pharmacist]

I believe Hg15 is a townie, just trying too hard and singing toes for nothing. If anything it muddies the water when there actually will be something to go on. At this point, any lynching will have to be random, as any strategy will end up with a random answer. I'm good with any strategy for day 1

[Completely]

Gah, i have no idea who to vote for. Who's in charge of the pitchforks?

[kermitology]

I agree Hockeyguy15 is just playing "hard" at the moment. It's not particularly suspicious in my mind, just eager.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

It is a good strategy for HG to step up, either his is Town and helps lead to victory or he is a snake leading lemmings off a cliff.

Either option will eventually lend itself to a "I told ya so" or "I played you fools". Now to only decide if he is trustworthy or misleading.

flameswin throwing out the vote for yourself was really strange, I know it was supposed to be a joke but that's just weird.

This specific quote is what I meant by sitting on the fence. Either lead to victory or lead to the cliff. Either I told you so or I played you. Is he trustworth or misleading.

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

Dang, two mafia groups to track will be tough. Especially since I trust no one.

GET OFF MY LAWN!!!!

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

Sticking up for your Mafia buddy?

These 2 quotes mention mafia. Everyone else seems to have posts about strategy or their thoughts but you always seem to have a mafia specific post.

Again I could be wrong, but these are just my obervations so far.

[Street Pharmacist]

As an aside, I have no idea what was changed to "singing toes" by SwiftKey on my previous post, but it stands

[Completely]

I think Hockey is just trying to stir the pot and get the game going. Just a tad over eager.

[Kjesse]

Originally Posted by Completely

I think Hockey is just trying to stir the pot and get the game going. Just a tad over eager.

Somebody has to do it. He's promoting more posts, and it works. I made a small call out to Aeneas, not an aggressive one because my info wasn't great, but look what he did, he posted, objective achieved. So far I'm satisfied with his response. That info will become helpful later.

This game is kind of like whack-a-mole where first you poke them to see what they do.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by Delgar

Somebody has to do it. He's promoting more posts, and it works. I made a small call out to Aeneas, not an aggressive one because my info wasn't great, but look what he did, he posted, objective achieved. So far I'm satisfied with his response. That info will become helpful later.

This game is kind of like whack-a-mole where first you poke them to see what they do.

It sounds like you weren't very good at whack-a-mole

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

Seems to me that only mafia would be so rude and uncaring of fellow town people..

And only mafia people deal in absolutes.

[CofR]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

As an aside, I have no idea what was changed to "singing toes" by SwiftKey on my previous post, but it stands

Mafia code haha?

[Crazy Bacon Legs]

So I set up a dice-rolling tournament in order to figure out who I should vote for at random. It's a random game that this point and there's no sense in applying logic, as far as I can tell.

I assigned three dice to each person: two red and one black for those who played the game before, and two white and one red for those of us who are new. I included myself in this process. It's only fair. What I was really struck by is the fact that I own such a large number of dice for no real reason.

I began by laying out the dice on a large table and setting people up based on a snaking alphabetical list. My plan was to stage an elimination-style bracket tournament with the "winner" being voted on by me to die.

I started rolling the dice when suddenly the cat ran in and grabbed one of the red dice and ran off with it. Which is weird, because I don't own a cat. I spent the next 45 minutes looking for the cat, and when I came back to the table the cleaning lady had cleaned up all my dice. I was again struck by the oddness of this as I do not have a cleaning lady. So some woman came into my house and stole all my dice.

This is a long way of telling you I still don't know how to vote. I have another selection method involving a lawn mower. I will let you know if this works out. But I have discovered that I really need to get my door fixed. It's like a bloody train station in here.

[kermitology]

God damn I love it when CBL posts.