2026 Cavalry FC and CPL thread

[MillerTime GFG]

Originally Posted by shermanator

If he progresses in APL, I imagine at some point in the next year Jax will sign a first team deal. And that will not go over well with some.

He creates chances. Finds the right spots. But he misses A LOT of said chances, and I don’t think that’s gonna change.

[Jimmy Stang]

Originally Posted by Slava

I also don’t see how it’s lunacy and it seems like a common sense approach to offside to me.

The main issue that I see with it is that instead of measuring a knee past the defender, we'll be measuring a knee inside the daylight zone. Six of one, half a dozen of the other.

Ultimately it is a change that gives attackers an advantage. As far as offside goes, the line has simply been moved from the last defender to the last defender plus a gap. If adopted in VAR leagues, the VAR will still be counting pixels, just on a different line.

[Slava]

Well VAR is a whole other issue and discussion. I'm against it and I think these initiatives in sports in general just aren't positives. I can admit that I was thinking that they were going to be great and solve so many things, but the truth is that it's made things worse. Looking at pixels or millimeters to make these decisions is just stupid.

And we still have mistakes and terrible calls anyway. We haven't fixed anything in that regard, and just added more irritation and a poorer experience for fans.

[Jimmy Stang]

^ VAR aside, I think that the daylight rule will actually be more difficult to call and make offsides fuzzier. I guess that's the point to some. Instead of having an object (last defender) as the line, we now have a fuzzy "last defender plus some space".

I think that the ambiguity will be frustrating for players, officials, and viewers. Attackers, however, will love it.

[Bill Bumface]

Originally Posted by Slava

Well VAR is a whole other issue and discussion. I'm against it and I think these initiatives in sports in general just aren't positives. I can admit that I was thinking that they were going to be great and solve so many things, but the truth is that it's made things worse. Looking at pixels or millimeters to make these decisions is just stupid.

And we still have mistakes and terrible calls anyway. We haven't fixed anything in that regard, and just added more irritation and a poorer experience for fans.

I agree, and while it's frustrating watching CPL games when a call is totally botched, I will trade that every time for the fact that when a big goal goes in I can actually enjoy the moment instead of looking around nervously to see if my candy is going to be taken away.

[TheIronMaiden]

Originally Posted by Bill Bumface

I agree, and while it's frustrating watching CPL games when a call is totally botched, I will trade that every time for the fact that when a big goal goes in I can actually enjoy the moment instead of looking around nervously to see if my candy is going to be taken away.

Even with botched calls now and then the better team wins 99% of the time.

[Jimmy Stang]

Originally Posted by Bill Bumface

I agree, and while it's frustrating watching CPL games when a call is totally botched, I will trade that every time for the fact that when a big goal goes in I can actually enjoy the moment instead of looking around nervously to see if my candy is going to be taken away.

Originally Posted by TheIronMaiden

Even with botched calls now and then the better team wins 99% of the time.

Which makes me feel that this is a VAR problem, and not an offside problem. "Old school", human-called offside is naturally a little fuzzy anyway. Sometimes it benefits the defender, sometimes the attacker. Sometimes it is spot on, and other times it is blatantly wrong.

The daylight offside rule is a response to VAR and pixel counting, but I feel that it misses the mark as we'll still end up counting pixels - just now it will be a toe past the daylight zone vs. a toe past the defender.

And for the CPL, a non-VAR league, it will just create confusion and frustration. So we have a non-VAR league testing a new offside rule that was brought about because of frustrations with VAR.

I guess we'll see how it plays out, and it is the same rules for all teams, etc. so it is fine. And might bring some international attention to the CPL - hopefully positive!

[The Big Chill]

I like the sound of the modified version of the daylight rule where they use torsos instead of any body part. That feels way closer to the spirit of the original rule where you are really just looking for an advantage gained by an attacker.

And ya, VAR sucks and the implementation of it has been completely botched. They’ve made it an additional ref rather than a system to fix obvious mistakes.

[shermanator]

Rumour mill saying Musse has re-signed.

[Redliner]

Originally Posted by shermanator

Rumour mill saying Musse has re-signed.

With the Cavs? Interesting. Kind of seemed like maybe there was some frustration with his inconsistency and that Tommy was ready to turn the page. I wonder if they were looking at someone specific to replace Musse then couldn't get that player.

[Mccree]

Was listening to the Footy Prime pod cast yesterday and they mentioned that Football Video Support is coming the the CPL apparently funded by FIFA

https://inside.fifa.com/innovation/n...-video-support

https://truenorthfoot.ca/article/foo...ed-to-know-420

[M*A*S*H 4077]

Gherasimencov has just entered the match for his Whitecaps and MLS debut. That’s our boy!