CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Timbo]

starseed did you receive this information in the "night of the game"
or "last night" real time?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Timbo

starseed did you receive this information in the "night of the game"
or "last night" real time?

What information?

Am I wrong in assuming he was lying about the Hockeyguy15 investigation?

I'm confused.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

What information?

Am I wrong in assuming he was lying about the Hockeyguy15 investigation?

I'm confused.

Ya that's what I'm asking is when he received this HG15 information? He said "last night" I want clarification. As I am not sure when he meant.

[Drury18]

So Starseed, you essentially just did the same thing you were doing as MOT's (while anonymous) but outside of the Twilight thread?

Pick a person you have a hunch on, name them, hope we do the dirty work for you?

[Hockeyguy15]

I'm still here, just speechless. It was all a lie to try and get me lynched?

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Drury18

So Starseed, you essentially just did the same thing you were doing as MOT's (while anonymous) but outside of the Twilight thread?

Pick a person you have a hunch on, name them, hope we do the dirty work for you?

Essentially. Again, we have a better chance at hitting mafia than the 3 other townies do.

[Timbo]

Right now I am trying to wrap my head around starseeds total involvement in this game and it twists like a strand of DNA.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by starseed

Essentially. Again, we have a better chance at hitting mafia than the 3 other townies do.

Yes but when have you? The MOT accusations were all bad not including Girly
And The vote placement is all over the place looking to incite easy lynching?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Bunch of lies and the only reason he stopped was because he was caught in one more thanks to Timbo's bucket. It didn't, still doesn't, make sense to question my power. My alignment? Sure, I guess. But how can I not be an investigator?

Even after Starseed reveals that he was lying, Puxlut keeps going. I say Starseed should give us his top suspect and then we lynch him. Let him finally prove some claims. So many lies from the very beginning of the game about time we get him out in my opinion.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

I say Starseed should give us his top suspect and then we lynch him.

Him being Starseed and not whoever is his top suspect

[Timbo]

I'm not sure if this was a bad night or a good night to have a couple of beers.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Timbo

I'm not sure if this was a bad night or a good night to have a couple of beers.

I wanted to go to bed early because I had hockey last night. So much for that!

[Timbo]

I still feel starseed is pulling us away from Puxlut

[Drury18]

Well to be completely honest, knowing that I probably don't live past tonight, I really have a hard time lynching someone who I'm not fully convinced about over someone whose openly lied to the town.

I need to give the town the best chance going forward and keeping someone whose lied so much is something I'm having a hard time justifying. I don't know if I'm helping you to win keeping someone who I'm sure most of us are going to have a hard time trusting now is it.

I have no more powers and I think I'm running out of time. My mindset now is getting the town to the end with the best chance to win because I'm not going to be there to help. I think getting rid of our liar is what I have to do.

Diss and Timbo, you two have been on my town list since the start of the game. You still are. Obviously as I put my own ass on the line to save Timbo. His bucket and his hider ability is town. There's no two ways. Diss, the fact you can make someone unlynchable and put a vote on them reads to me as town aligned. You also turned down invites and powers. HG15, you are up there too. Starseed's claim was false, I can't figure out why scum would rewind a day. The fact you got to do it privately made me wonder, but you were open about it before using it. So at that point, you screwed yourself if you were scum and were trying to help someone hide. That would have become pretty obvious, pretty quick. Oling, to be honest I can't read you at all. You kinda sit in limbo for me, which isn't a slam, I just get the whole GGG like feeling with you. So many votes, so many theories, I really have to pay attention with you. I know you haven't lied about me, and you can back most things up but I still wonder about you. Starseed was on my initial scum list. Like initial, first day, scrap piece of paper writing down names list. His posts just struck me as odd. Then the MOT thing. Then the group thing. Now the lying thing. It's alot to overlook. Puxlut, I don't know if she's blindly following along Starseed or Mastermind of it all. Or someone caught in over her head and struggling to find up.

Diss, Timbo and HG...I know I'm supposed to think for myself, but do you think getting rid of the liar sets you up the best to win?

[Timbo]

starseeds deceit is well documented. I agree we have to get rid of the liar. However I think starseeds absence was due to his fabrication of a ruse to make us vote for him.
I have distrusted starseed from the origins of this game and even told GGG not to drink starseeds coolaid as it was poison.Yet I still feel his fate is tied into Puxluts and her demise is his. I think his demise is not hers and therefore still gives scum that one more chance to win. So he makes a deliberate lie/deciet and a sudden admission of it?
This is the second time he has done so. MOT was number 1
This is number two
In both instances he deflects from Puxlut. This seems very odd to me.
Other than hmmhmmmcamo I think my instincts have proven good.
I will however concede to you and your way of though if you need my vote.

[Timbo]

um I mean way of thought

[Hockeyguy15]

At this point I can't really trust anything starseed says. I don't like that he lied to try and get me lynched, then he would have us lose another to the night kill in order to get the numbers down so that him/Puxlut/their extra vote would be enough to control the game. I'm going to sleep on it, but I think I agree and that we can't keep him around after all the manipulating he has done.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

Like initial, first day, scrap piece of paper writing down names list. His posts just struck me as odd. Then the MOT thing. Then the group thing. Now the lying thing. It's alot to overlook. Puxlut, I don't know if she's blindly following along Starseed or Mastermind of it all. Or someone caught in over her head and struggling to find up.

Yes, and he was on that list with other mafia right?

Even if you don't trust me, I don't have the extra vote. If Puxlut and Starseed are mafia, we need to vote one of them out or we lose.

If someone else is mafia, we still might have a chance tomorrow as it will be 3-2, especially if you trust diss.

Starseed has been lying since day 1 when he came up with the MOT. He might have saved Baxter/Aeneas that day. Girlysports defended him religiously. When I suggest they lynch me and then vote for him, he turns the vote away because he knew I would show town and people would trust me enough to look at what I was saying. Now he goes after Hockeyguy15 and somehow comes to the conclusion if Hockeyguy15 revealed town that Diss and Timbo are mafia? He's been saying me and Timbo are connected most of the game.

Why did SS unvote when he thought that HG have proven himself town by mentioning something that SS thought proved him town. (Does that make sense?)
I think we were on to something until SS screwed up with the "forces of light" post.

For half a second SS thought HG was town and unvoted.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

Why did SS unvote when he thought that HG have proven himself town by mentioning something that SS thought proved him town..

No he unvoted when he realized that Timbo would prove my investigator claim ruining his "theory", he just came up with a stupid reason to make us second guess everything again. He's been manipulating us the entire time.

And even you tried to come up with a way town could win if starseed was mafia and wasn't lynched, why? You should know he wasn't mafia? To me that looks like a major slip-up.