CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Hockeyguy15]

What are you talking about with night kills? Only mafia can do night kills.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by agulati

But I would rather wait for Mazrim to weigh in. If transplant doesn't post more or Mazrim doesn't mod-kill him, we should only then lynch him. No point wasting a night kill, if we can get him taken care off by Mazrim.

Let our "mod" also get his hands red. :P

Based on the last game, if Mazrim mod-kills him for non-participation he'll just get replaced with someone new in the same role. That's what happened with Sliver last game, and there were one or two back-ups who volunteered to be replacements if necessary.

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by agulati

Very mafia-like statement there CC.

Really? Or is it just something that CaptainCrunch would say?

We went through this in the last game, and it was wrong, I think that we bank way to much on things like posting style, when we should be looking for who's guiding votes and why.

Logic kind of states that the Mafia won't guide the vote hard until later in the game, the odds are inversly in their favor because they know town does more damage in the opening few rounds to themselves.

When I watched HG tossing out suspicions, its why I have a distrust of him as scum.

The fact that you took something that I said that was fairly innocuous and tried to turn it makes me want to point a finger at you

(that's a joke by the way)

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by agulati

But I would rather wait for Mazrim to weigh in. If transplant doesn't post more or Mazrim doesn't mod-kill him, we should only then lynch him. No point wasting a night kill, if we can get him taken care off by Mazrim.

Let our "mod" also get his hands red. :P

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

What are you talking about with night kills? Only mafia can do night kills.

Good catch

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by agulati

But I would rather wait for Mazrim to weigh in. If transplant doesn't post more or Mazrim doesn't mod-kill him, we should only then lynch him. No point wasting a night kill, if we can get him taken care off by Mazrim.

Let our "mod" also get his hands red. :P

did we post something in the wrong thread?

[CaptainCrunch]

That Agulati post is making me itch in terms of the night kill, it almost reads like a post in the wrong thread. I'm throwing a vote out there, just to see if there's a confession.



Vote Agulati

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

did we post something in the wrong thread?

Or maybe a Freudian slip. Definitely moves agulati up the suspects list, imo.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by agulati

So we now know that ineedanother is definitely town, but his target so far has been unfortunately on townsfolk.

I will personally be vary of his recommendations for now.

As for mafia, I am concerned with Rathji. He unvoted after all the votes had been cast. It almost seems like he did that, so at a future date that claim can be made, that he did not end up voting for ineedanother. This might be because he is playing for the first time, and I am off completely though.

But when he unvoted it had nothing to do with ineedanother, it was hmmhmmcamo.

[agulati]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

did we post something in the wrong thread?

Haha brainfart. Most of our lynches happen at night hence I said night kill.

[Hockeyguy15]

Yeah CC, agulati seems weird right now. I went back and read his posts and none of them really seemed to be anything about mafia hunting until is post about Rathji.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by agulati

Haha brainfart. Most of our lynches happen at night hence I said night kill.

Weak post, I am not sure if that will save your neck.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by agulati

Haha brainfart. Most of our lynches happen at night hence I said night kill.

What? All the lynches are during the day.

We are not allowed to post at night.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

That Agulati post is making me itch in terms of the night kill, it almost reads like a post in the wrong thread. I'm throwing a vote out there, just to see if there's a confession.



Vote Agulati

I will second that e-motion since we have lots of time before hammer can start.

Vote: agulati

[CaptainCrunch]

You know what would be nice for old people like this.

If there was a way to break days down into sub threads so that we won't have to go through hundreds of pages of posts to find a needle in a haystack.

Is there any way that you can do sub threads?

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by agulati

So we now know that ineedanother is definitely town, but his target so far has been unfortunately on townsfolk.

Another post of yours that is weird.

We knew ineedanother was town before, once he used his day kill. Why are you saying this now?

[starseed]

Originally Posted by agulati

So we now know that ineedanother is definitely town, but his target so far has been unfortunately on townsfolk.

I will personally be vary of his recommendations for now.

I think we just need to get ineedanother to avoid voting before we have had a lot of discussion, then he can decide based on the evidence that everyone else has discussed. It may have failed early, but I still think it is our best strategy, if we go about it more deliberately.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

You know what would be nice for old people like this.

If there was a way to break days down into sub threads so that we won't have to go through hundreds of pages of posts to find a needle in a haystack.

Is there any way that you can do sub threads?

Mazrim posts links to the different events in the first post.

[agulati]

Also CC, my post about your statement was based as a joke because I had wrongly thought you were mafia last game. Currently I don't see anything necessarily pointing you as a member of either of the mafia groups.

I am personally wary of
1. Rathji
2. Transplant
3. HD

I will wait to cast a vote though, giving all of them a chance to post.

[CaptainCrunch]

I agree on the deliberate, but the nice thing about the vote is the unvote, there's no harm in loading up votes on a person as long as that last vote doesn't come until nearer to the deadline.

People act in a different way when they're sitting under a sword tied to the ceiling by a single hair.

I might be wrong on Agulati.

It might be inexperience, but that he takes a line from me about burying our dead and moving on and points the mafia bomb at me, with the old hey that sounds like a mob thing to say

1) Tries to sublty influence the vote

2) The weird post that honestly reads like something you'd see in a mafia planning discussion about not wasting a nightkill.

3) A really weak defense post that points to night vote.

To me at the very least, we make him squirm a bit under a vote count and see what happens.

He could be an inexperienced player that screwed up and is now in quick sand.

He could be a mob member that jumped at something then scrambled and now he's trying to deflect out of it badly.

[CaptainCrunch]

Man this game makes you jumpy.

Right now, I'm really looking at Agulati (Slip up) Rathji (history) Transplant (activity), HG (Feels like he was really trying to point 8 million fingers)