Doin Phanf Marries Elisha Cuthbert - Garbage Thread Alert

[_Q_]

Originally Posted by GreenLantern2814

He's a top 20 D in this league. Plays the tough minutes, not the most lock down guy but he plays with way more patience.

His hip injuries and leg laceration really screwed up his skating, he's not nearly the explosive player he was when he broke in. He may yet win a Norris, his offence has come back, and he's getting to that age where defensemen really figure out their own zone.

Put it this way, the last thing we need is for Toronto to ship him to Edmonton. Back to us would be better

HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.

Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.

[moon]

Originally Posted by _Q_

HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.

Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.

If the Leafs can get to OT of game 7 (a game most would agree they should have won) against a Stanley Cup finalist with an "AHL grade" defenseman getting the most minutes, playing in the key moments and leading the team in defensemen scoring then all the haters better lookout because that team must be super talented outside of Dion to make up for his AHL level play.

4 defensemen on the Flames over Dion? LOL

I know people have irrational hatred of him but sometimes it truly is funny to see the hate.

[Poe969]

I heard that right at the begining of the reception, Dion walked up to the DJ stand and changed the music just to show he was in charge.

[GreenLantern2814]

Originally Posted by _Q_

HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.

Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.

The only D I'd take over him is Brodie, and that's only because I think Brodie is going to be a star in 18 months.

Giordano has one season that's anywhere close to Phaneuf's middle of the road. Not one D on our roster can impact the game physically, to say nothing of their ability to do it at phaneuf's level.

Everyone thought he was the next great generational talent at the position. He's not. He is a number one D on a playoff team. Which means he doesn't suck nearly as much as you think he does. And he certainly isn't an ahl d. And when you say you'd take four current flames over him, you're lying.

[minnow]

Congrats, hope they're happy and can make it last! Good luck to them. The snide remarks are pretty sad really, but not unexpected.

[Cleveland Steam Whistle]

Originally Posted by Regulator75

She's only 30? Looks like she's pushing 40.

Please post picture of self.

[StrykerSteve]

Originally Posted by _Q_

HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.

Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.

The jealousy in this thread is ridiculous.

[Poe969]

LOL, I think if we could pick up Dion, we should. He isn't bad let alone horrible. I'm happy for him but I feel sorry for him because he's in toronto and he has a big contract. When he's making less on his next contract, teams will line up to get him.

[Bertuzzied]

Originally Posted by Cleveland Steam Whistle

Please post picture of self.

She has never looked the same since season 3 of 24 with her terrible bowl cut. My god what was she thinking?

[T@T]

Originally Posted by byronkentgraham

Jealousy will get you nowhere. Just sayin.

I think everyone in here would take it if givin to them...but I have a feeling 99% would immediately call a realtor to sell it...if you painted it red it would just be a barn.

[Ark2]

Originally Posted by _Q_

HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.

Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.

Absolute nonsense. I think top 20 is spot-on actually.

[GreenLantern2814]

Originally Posted by T@T

I think everyone in here would take it if givin to them...but I have a feeling 99% would immediately call a realtor to sell it...if you painted it red it would just be a barn.

That's prime PEI real estate; who cares what it looks like, a place that size comes with vassals.

[JeanLucPicard]

hopefully the paparazzi are getting ready for some good honeymoon shots. lots of money to be made.

[Hockey_Ninja]

Originally Posted by MissTeeks

This saddens me.

Why?

[Flames89]

One of those barns is his gym and bar. Supposed to be very tricked out inside.

[troutman]

Originally Posted by Ark2

Absolute nonsense. I think top 20 is spot-on actually.

He's not close to top 20. There are 0-3 d-men on 29 other teams that are better. The Leafs are trying to unload him, if the rumors are true. He is not an AHL d-man either. He has plateaued. Compare that to Subban, who improved his game.

[Ozy_Flame]

There's actually a garage for his truck too - and it has a lock on it!

[The Yen Man]

Originally Posted by _Q_

HAHA... no he's not. He's AHL grade.

Let's put it this way, I would take 4 of our defencemen over Dion any day of the week. He's absolutely horrible.

While I don't think he's a top 20 Dman, don't kid yourself. If he were on the Flames, he'd probably be anywhere between top 1-4, depending on preference. Like a poster said, I'd probably take Brodie over him, and that's based on potential rather than actual current play.