NHL 15 calgary flames player ratings

[savardandjokinen]

What do you guys think?

[Red John]

They look great.

[Monahan23]

Glencross (83) - Backlund(84) - Hudler (85)
Raymond (82) - Monahan(83) - Colborne (82)
Gaudreau (79) - Stajan (81) - Jones (79)
Baertschi (80) - Bouma (79) - McGrattan (72)
Byron (81) M. Reinhart (76) Bollig (76)

Giordano (88) - Brodie (84)
Russell (82) - Wideman (81)
Smid (84) - Engelland (78)
Cundari (75)

Hiller (85)
Ramo (83)

[Geeoff]

EA's player ratings are such a fail. We had one of the worst teams in the league and most of our players are gonna be in the 80s. Like is McGrattan really 75% as good as Crosby?

[Red John]

Where is the source for these ratings.

[btimbit]

Keeping in mind that the game is made in Vancouver and underrates Flames players (or at least overrates Canucks and Oilers) here's my guesses.

Raymond (82) - Backlund (84) - Hudler (83)
Glencross (83) - Stajan (81) - Jones (79)
Gaudreau (75) - Monahan (80) - Colborne (78)
Bollig (73) - Bouma (74) - McGrattan (70)
Baertschi (72) - Byron (74)

Giordano (86) - Brodie (84)
Russell (83) - Wideman (83)
Smid (80) - Engalland (76)
Wotherspoon (75)

Hiller (84)
Ramo (82)

[N-E-B]

Originally Posted by Geeoff

EA's player ratings are such a fail. We had one of the worst teams in the league and most of our players are gonna be in the 80s.

Not that I really care a whole lot about video games, but they do that to balance the teams and make it more realistic. The difference between the top NHLers and bottom ones really isn't that much. Most NHL players should be 80's.

[savardandjokinen]

Originally Posted by btimbit

Keeping in mind that the game is made in Vancouver and underrates Flames players (or at least overrates Canucks and Oilers) here's my guesses.

Raymond (82) - Backlund (84) - Hudler (83)
Glencross (83) - Stajan (81) - Jones (79)
Gaudreau (75) - Monahan (80) - Colborne (78)
Bollig (73) - Bouma (74) - McGrattan (70)
Baertschi (72) - Byron (74)

Giordano (86) - Brodie (84)
Russell (83) - Wideman (83)
Smid (80) - Engalland (76)
Wotherspoon (75)

Hiller (84)
Ramo (82)

I'd say a couple are too small but realistically could happen

[Monahan23]

for prospects I'd say

Granlund 4 Y
Reinhart 3.5 Y
Poirier 4 G
Klimchuk 4 G
Ortio 3.5G
Knight 3.5Y
Wotherspoon 4Y
Arnold 3.5Y
Baertschi 4.5Y
Kulak 4R
Sieloff 3.5Y
McDonald 4 Y
Smith 3.5 R
Hickey 3 Y
Gillies 4 G
Jankowski 4 R
Bennett 4.5 Y
Monahan 4.5 Y
Gaudreau 4.5 Y
Ferland 3.5 Y

[savardandjokinen]

Originally Posted by Monahan23

for prospects I'd say

Granlund 4 Y
Reinhart 3.5 Y
Poirier 4 G
Klimchuk 4 G
Ortio 3.5G
Knight 3.5Y
Wotherspoon 4Y
Arnold 3.5Y
Baertschi 4.5Y
Kulak 4R
Sieloff 3.5Y
McDonald 4 Y
Smith 3.5 R
Hickey 3 Y
Gillies 4 G
Jankowski 4 R
Bennett 4.5 Y
Monahan 4.5 Y

What about gaudreau but nice list

[Ashasx]

Wait have they been released or is this just guessing?

[TjRhythmic]

Originally Posted by btimbit

Keeping in mind that the game is made in Vancouver and underrates Flames players (or at least overrates Canucks and Oilers) here's my guesses.

Raymond (82) - Backlund (84) - Hudler (83)
Glencross (83) - Stajan (81) - Jones (79)
Gaudreau (75) - Monahan (80) - Colborne (78)
Bollig (73) - Bouma (74) - McGrattan (70)
Baertschi (72) - Byron (74)

Giordano (86) - Brodie (84)
Russell (83) - Wideman (83)
Smid (80) - Engalland (76)
Wotherspoon (75)

Hiller (84)
Ramo (82)

EA doesn't do the ratings. They have an unbiased third party that does the ratings

[dissentowner]

Gaudreau is so good he is unrankable.

[btimbit]

Originally Posted by TjRhythmic

EA doesn't do the ratings. They have an unbiased third party that does the ratings

I thought after 12 they went back to doing it themselves.

Originally Posted by Ashasx

Wait have they been released or is this just guessing?

Guessing.

[iLoveLamp]

Glencross (82) - Backlund (83) - Hudler (85)
Raymond (81) - Monahan (82) - Colborne (78)
Gaudreau (76) - Stajan (80) - Jones (78)
Bollig (76) - Byron (76) - McGrattan (73)
Bouma (75)

Giordano (87) - Brodie (83)
Russell (81) - Wideman (82)
Smid (80) - Engelland (77)
Wotherspoon (75)

Hiller (85)
Ramo (82)

[Psytic]

Originally Posted by Geeoff

EA's player ratings are such a fail. We had one of the worst teams in the league and most of our players are gonna be in the 80s. Like is McGrattan really 75% as good as Crosby?

He has a 100% rating in face punching though so it brings his average up.

[Muta]

I miss the days when older NHL games ranked players more accurately.

For example, an NHL tweener, or someone who was an additional forward or defenseman (or even the first call-up) would be ranked below 70, or low 70's (this is where young guys with potential would also be ranked). 3rd liners were ranked in the 70's, 2nd liners and their equivalents would be ranked in the high 70's / low 80's, elite players ranked in the mid-to-high 80's and superstars (like Jarome Iginla at the time) ranked in the low 90's. Higher than that would be reserved for generational talents like Gretzky or Lemieux.

Now, everyone is ranked within literally 5 points of each other, yet in real life, they'd never be that equal based on a variety of reasons including skill, consistency, injury proneness and so forth.

[Psytic]

Originally Posted by Muta

I miss the days when older NHL games ranked players more accurately.

For example, an NHL tweener, or someone who was an additional forward or defenseman (or even the first call-up) would be ranked below 70, or low 70's (this is where young guys with potential would also be ranked). 3rd liners were ranked in the 70's, 2nd liners and their equivalents would be ranked in the high 70's / low 80's, elite players ranked in the mid-to-high 80's and superstars (like Jarome Iginla at the time) ranked in the low 90's. Higher than that would be reserved for generational talents like Gretzky or Lemieux.

Now, everyone is ranked within literally 5 points of each other, yet in real life, they'd never be that equal based on a variety of reasons including skill, consistency, injury proneness and so forth.

NHL 94 on Genesis and Ice Hockey for the NES is all you need to this day still.

[TSXCman]

Originally Posted by savardandjokinen

What do you guys think?

So... what do I think about what?

Where are the ratings?

Also, are you drunk?

[Hugh Jahrmes]

I miss wraparound goals on snes. And one timers from the point.