[News] NHL 15 calgary flames official player ratings

[savardandjokinen]

Glencross-85
Backlund-82
Hudler-85
Gaudreau-76
Monahan-84
Raymond-85
Byron-78
Stajan-83
Jones-83
Bouma-77
Colborne-80
Setoguchi-84
Bollig-79
Mcgrattan-74
Baertschi-78
Giordano-87
Brodie-81
Smid-82
Wideman-84
Russell-80
Engelland-78
Hiller-87
Ramo-85

[jg13]

Highest to Lowest:

Giordano-87
Hiller-87
Hudler-85
Glencross-85
Raymond-85
Ramo-85
Monahan-84
Setoguchi-84
Wideman-84
Stajan-83
Jones-83
Backlund-82
Smid-82
Brodie-81
Russell-80
Colborne-80
Bollig-79
Byron-78
Baertschi-78
Engelland-78
Bouma-77
Gaudreau-76
Mcgrattan-74

[AC]

Did David Jones rise?

IMO, Stajan is too high as well, while Backlund, Brodie, and Russell are all too low.

[Ashasx]

Chris Tanev is rated higher than Brodie.

[btimbit]

Brodie too low. Rest seem OK

[FlamesFanStrandedInEDM]

Those seem pretty generous....

Specifically....
Raymond 85
Setoguchi 84

[indes]

I don't see how Monahan is better than Backlund, and brodie

[codynw]

Giordano, Backlund and Brodie are too low. Hiller, Raymond, Ramo, Monahan, Setoguchi and Jones are too high. The rest seem okay.

[formulate]

Smid higher than Brodie made me smile.

[savardandjokinen]

You guys are completely right

[H2SO4(aq)]

Backlund should be a 93

[MrMike]

Originally Posted by H2SO4(aq)

Backlund should be a 93

Green Text?

[bluloc]

Pretty good but I think Brodie should be an 83.

[Ashasx]

This is how I would have done it:

Glencross: 83
Backlund: 84
Hudler: 85
Monahan: 81
Raymond: 81
Byron: 78
Stajan: 81
Jones: 79
Bouma: 79
Colborne: 79
Setoguchi: 80
Bollig: 78
McGrattan: 75
Giordano: 89
Brodie: 85
Smid: 80
Wideman: 82
Russell: 81
Engelland: 76

Hiller: 84
Ramo: 83

[Finger Cookin]

Originally Posted by H2SO4(aq)

Backlund should be a 93

That's Bennett.

[TSXCman]

Keep in mind these ratings aren't averages. I think they are how much of the player type attributes are full. Eg. Defensive dman is going to be low if he can't hit or poke, but may still have high skating, passing etc.

So they always seem out of whack.

[Wastedyouth]

I see we are at annual "get bent out of shape because of video game ratings" time of the year again.

Right on!

[ForeverFlameFan]

I think the ratings should be these, and I will probably edit them to these too:

Glencross-85 (-2) = 83
Backlund-82 (+2) = 84
Hudler-85 (0) = 85
Gaudreau-76 (+2) = 78
Monahan-84 (-2) = 82
Raymond-85 (-3) = 82
Byron-78 (+1) = 79
Stajan-83 (-2) = 81
Jones-83 (-5) = 78
Bouma-77 (-1) = 76
Colborne-80 (0) = 80
Setoguchi-84 (-6) = 78
Bollig-79 (-3) = 76
Mcgrattan-74 (-2) = 72
Baertschi-78 (0) = 78
Giordano-87 (+2) = 89
Brodie-81 (+4) = 85
Smid-82 (0) = 82
Wideman-84 (-1) = 83
Russell-80 (+1) = 81
Engelland-78 (-1) = 77
Hiller-87 (-2) = 85
Ramo-85 (-2) = 83

I will be subtracting a lot more than adding the original overall, they really overrated our team, especially the goalies.

[codynw]

"Hiller played so badly that he got pushed off the Ducks roster, but lets make his rating even higher than it was last year!"

Originally Posted by ForeverFlameFan

I think the ratings should be these, and I will probably edit them to these too:

Spoiler!

Glencross-85 (-2) = 83
Backlund-82 (+2) = 84
Hudler-85 (0) = 85
Gaudreau-76 (+2) = 78
Monahan-84 (-2) = 82
Raymond-85 (-3) = 82
Byron-78 (+1) = 79
Stajan-83 (-2) = 81
Jones-83 (-5) = 78
Bouma-77 (-1) = 76
Colborne-80 (0) = 80
Setoguchi-84 (-6) = 78
Bollig-79 (-3) = 76
Mcgrattan-74 (-2) = 72
Baertschi-78 (0) = 78
Giordano-87 (+2) = 89
Brodie-81 (+4) = 85
Smid-82 (0) = 82
Wideman-84 (-1) = 83
Russell-80 (+1) = 81
Engelland-78 (-1) = 77
Hiller-87 (-2) = 85
Ramo-85 (-2) = 83

I will be subtracting a lot more than adding the original overall, they really overrated our team, especially the goalies.

You can't edit players this year.

[savardandjokinen]

Originally Posted by codynw

"Hiller played so badly that he got pushed off the Ducks roster, but lets make his rating even higher than it was last year!"



You can't edit players this year.

That's only for xbox one and ps4. PS3 and 360 can do everything from 14