Soooo

[MJK]

delete

[dsavillian]

nah

[JiriHrdina]

you go first.

[TurdFerguson]

Vrana
Kempe
McKeown
Schmaltz
MacInnis
Bleackley
Scherbak
Goldobin
Kamenev
Sanheim

[MJK]

delete

[GreenLantern]

[MJK]

Geeze if we get GreenLantern posting this thread must be a fail.

Please delete.

[dsavillian]

Originally Posted by GreenLantern

2nd best meme post of the off-season so far.

Devo's Oprah meme was better.

[The Swedish Flame]

This thread gets 10/10. Would read again.

[Da_Chief]

I think we need a Purge.

[MJK]

I feel bad for any potential new GM's who might stumble in a thread like this only to see a bunch of GM's attempting to be comedians instead of participating as per the original title.

In the future if you don't want to participate or don't have anything of value to add to the discussion, don't post.

[JiriHrdina]

Originally Posted by MJK

I feel bad for any potential new GM's who might stumble in a thread like this only to see a bunch of GM's attempting to be comedians instead of participating as per the original title.

In the future if you don't want to participate or don't have anything of value to add to the discussion, don't post.

Some friendly ribbing is part of any good league.
But you didn't really think anyone would post their projections did you? It reveals far too much about how each GM values prospects.

[dsavillian]

Originally Posted by MJK

I feel bad for any potential new GM's who might stumble in a thread like this only to see a bunch of GM's attempting to be comedians instead of participating as per the original title.

In the future if you don't want to participate or don't have anything of value to add to the discussion, don't post.

Who are you and what have you done with MJK?


edit: green text implied

[MJK]

Originally Posted by JiriHrdina

Some friendly ribbing is part of any good league.
But you didn't really think anyone would post their projections did you? It reveals far too much about how each GM values prospects.

When top 10 picks are owed by 4 GM's, whats the harm for the rest of the league to post their projected top 10 as they think they will go.

I didnt say 'post your top 10 guys', I asked who do you think will go top 10 in cphl draft, those are two very different things.

Regardless, 4 useless comments in a row means thread fail, my attempt to start an interesting discussion backfired.

[JiriHrdina]

Originally Posted by MJK

When top 10 picks are owed by 4 GM's, whats the harm for the rest of the league to post their projected top 10 as they think they will go.

I didnt say 'post your top 10 guys', I asked who do you think will go top 10 in cphl draft, those are two very different things.

Regardless, 4 useless comments in a row means thread fail, my attempt to start an interesting discussion backfired.

But projecting what players will go first is to a large degree based on GM perceptions about who the best players are.

So let's pretend I don't owe the #9 pick and instead I have the 13th as my first pick. I could post my top 10 and predict that Jake Virtanen is who I project to go at 10. He remains available after 10 - now the GMs with 11 and 12 have some idea that I likely will take Virtanen if available at 13 and can use that to inform their own pick or try to make a trade for me by threatening to take the guy I like.

Hey - I like the attempt for interesting discussion but seems reasonable that no one is going to reveal any sort of insight into what their list looks like.

[MJK]

Sure, u can delete the thread now, it sucks.

[Da_Chief]

So a Purge?

[MJK]

Originally Posted by Da_Chief

So a Purge?

Ya the CPHL could use a purge. It's pretty bad when I have to refer to the GM page to find out who someone is and what team they "manage".

GM's taking a week to respond to threads and PM's is painful.

[btimbit]

Originally Posted by MJK

Ya the CPHL could use a purge. It's pretty bad when I have to refer to the GM page to find out who someone is and what team they "manage".

GM's taking a week to respond to threads and PM's is painful.

There's guys popping in cheese's "GM's retiring" thread that I've never even seen post before.

[MJK]

I think we might be in a transition phase in the CPHL