Quote:
Originally Posted by Psytic
Hard to argue when you look at it like this. I'm curious to see the rebuttals though.
|
While appreciating the work put into it - the view is still too simple. Pass/fail is too binary.
For example these two drafts are classified both as "pass" when one is clearly MUCH better but that isn't accounted for at all.
2011 - Overall Grade - Pass
13th - Baertschi - Fail
45th - Granlund - Pass
57th - Wotherspoon - Fail
104th - Gaudreau - Pass
164th - Brossoit - Pass
2016 - Overall Grade - Pass
6th - Tkachuk - Pass
54th - Parsons - Fail
56th - Dube - Pass
66th - Fox - Pass
96th - Lindstrom - Fail
126th - Mattson - Fail
156th - Tuulola - TBD
166th - Phillips - TBD
186th - Falovsky - Fail