View Single Post
Old 05-28-2021, 04:18 PM   #51
Da_Chief
Franchise Player
 
Join Date: May 2007
Exp:
Default

Sutter gets a lot of flack for controlling the scouting department when he was here. He moved on in 2010.

So looking for from 2011 on Button has been in charge...Lets grade picks Pass or Fail

2011 - Overall Grade - Pass
13th - Baertschi - Fail
45th - Granlund - Pass
57th - Wotherspoon - Fail
104th - Gaudreau - Pass
164th - Brossoit - Pass

2012 - Overall Grade - Fail
21st - Jankowski - Fail
42nd - Sieloff - Fail
75th - GIllies - Fail
105th - Kulak - Pass
124th - Culkin - Fail
165th - Gordon - Fail
186th - DeBlouw - Fail

2013 - Overall Grade - Fail
6th - Monahan - Pass
22nd - Poirier - Fail
28th - Klimchuk - Fail
67th - Kanzig - Fail
135th - Roy - Fail
157th - Harrison - Fail
187th - Rafikov - Fail
198 - Gilmour - Fail

2014 - Overall Grade - Fail
4th - Bennett - Fail
34th - McDonald - Fail
54th - Smith - Fail
64th - Hickey - Fail
175th - Ollas-Mattson - Fail
184th - Carroll - Fail

2015 - Overall Grade - Pass
53rd - Andersson - Pass
60th - Kylington - his development has been stuck in 1st gear for about 4 years - Fail
136th - Karnaukhov - Fail
166th - Mangiapane - Pass
196th - Bruce - Fail

2016 - Overall Grade - Pass
6th - Tkachuk - Pass
54th - Parsons - Fail
56th - Dube - Pass
66th - Fox - Pass
96th - Lindstrom - Fail
126th - Mattson - Fail
156th - Tuulola - TBD
166th - Phillips - TBD
186th - Falovsky - Fail

2017 - Overall Grade - TBD
16th - Valimaki - TBD
109th - Ruzicka - TBD
140th - Fischer - Fail
171st - Joly - Fail
202nd - Sveningsson - Fail
Top 2 picks left from this draft, can they salvage it or another failed draft?

Too early to tell for 2018 on...

You have here 7 draft classes...You have 3 passes and 3 fails and 1 TBD...
You have 45 players selected...You have 10 passes...33 fails...2 TBD...

Diving into the 10 passes...
Players who have become par of the core, ie have got a 2nd big contract.
Gaudreau
Monahan
Takchuk
Andersson

Players who were traded away for whatever reason before they became something...
Kulak - 102 games as a Flame
Brossoit - 0 games as a Flame
Fox - 0 games as a Flame
Granlund - 86 games as a Flame

2 Others are Dube and Mangiapane...

Overall are you satisfied with this work? Honestly going into this exercise I though it would've been better.

I think its time for an overall organizational change. Pro scouting, amateur scouting, GMs office, coaches (leave Sutter I guess since he just came back).
Da_Chief is offline   Reply With Quote
The Following 6 Users Say Thank You to Da_Chief For This Useful Post: