Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post - NHL history in a 127 years of bite sized pieces.

Jay Random · 02-08-2024, 11:24 PM

Eddie Livingstone kind of had a reason to be a jerkface.

In 1916–17, the last season of the old National Hockey Association, the Canadian Army iced a professional team – 228th Battalion, the Northern Fusiliers. They played out of Toronto and drew huge crowds for every game.

Halfway through the season, the battalion was sent overseas and had to withdraw from the league. Rather than finish the schedule with an odd number of teams, the other owners voted to suspend Livingstone's Toronto Blueshirts without compensation. However, they demanded a $3,000 forfeit from the Army for not finishing the season (and were laughed out of court for it).

When the NHL formed, it gave the Arenas all the players Livingstone had under contract – again without compensation. Of course he sued the league, and the appeals dragged on for a decade. One of the judges declared, ‘I look on the conduct of the defendants as utterly dishonest and despicable,’ and regretted that he could find no precedent for awarding punitive damages.

There was enough jerkiness to go around in those days.

02-08-2024, 11:24 PM	#3
Jay Random Franchise Player Join Date: Aug 2005 Exp:	Eddie Livingstone kind of had a reason to be a jerkface. In 1916–17, the last season of the old National Hockey Association, the Canadian Army iced a professional team – 228th Battalion, the Northern Fusiliers. They played out of Toronto and drew huge crowds for every game. Halfway through the season, the battalion was sent overseas and had to withdraw from the league. Rather than finish the schedule with an odd number of teams, the other owners voted to suspend Livingstone's Toronto Blueshirts without compensation. However, they demanded a $3,000 forfeit from the Army for not finishing the season (and were laughed out of court for it). When the NHL formed, it gave the Arenas all the players Livingstone had under contract – again without compensation. Of course he sued the league, and the appeals dragged on for a decade. One of the judges declared, ‘I look on the conduct of the defendants as utterly dishonest and despicable,’ and regretted that he could find no precedent for awarding punitive damages. There was enough jerkiness to go around in those days. __________________ WARNING: The preceding message may not have been processed in a sarcasm-free facility. Last edited by Jay Random; 02-08-2024 at 11:26 PM.