Quote:
Originally Posted by 5abi
Right now it’s about weakening their immediate position and sending a message.
This is excellent use of a democratic tool
|
I’m thinking about a slippery slope. We recall one of their guys, they will try to recall ours. x 10.
People tried to recall Gondek. People camped outside her personal residence.
https://www.projectcalgary.org/recal...tion_is_a_flop
Quote:
Evidence obtained by Mount Royal University political scientist Duane Bratt reveals what appears to be a substantial organization behind the “grassroots” Recall Gondek campaign involving far-right UCP Board members and Take Back Alberta social conservatives.
CTV News reports that the document also includes a list of “high-profile” Albertans who have allegedly contributed tens of thousands of dollars to the campaign. According to CBC News, various members of the team are allegedly "paid, full-time" staff working 50 to 60 hours per week.
|
Google AI overview:
Arguments for recalls being undemocratic
Undermine stability: Some argue that the threat of a recall election can lead to political paralysis and instability.
Polarization: Recalls can be used as a political weapon, encouraging parties to sabotage opponents and increase polarization.
Undue influence: While proponents argue for more accountability, critics might argue that recalls can give disproportionate power to small groups of voters or political opponents to disrupt the democratic process.
"Chilling effect": The constant threat of a recall could make politicians risk-averse, discouraging them from making bold but necessary decisions.
Arguments against recalls being undemocratic
Enhance accountability: Supporters see recalls as a democratic tool to hold elected officials accountable to their constituents, especially when they believe an official is not serving their interests.
Increase representation: By giving the electorate a way to act between elections, recalls can give people a greater sense of being represented.
Strengthen the mandate: Some evidence suggests that recalls may have improved trust in government in certain contexts.
A check on power: Like other checks and balances in a democracy, recalls can prevent elected officials from overstepping their authority without fearing consequences.