[CalgaryFan1988]

Originally Posted by Arsenal14

I have 9 rankings saved from 2013:

Future Considerations: Jones 1, MacKinnon 2
Craig Button: Jones 1, Drouin 2, MacKinnon 3
McKeen: Jones 1, MacKinnon 2
CSS: Jones 1, MacKinnon 2

Bob McKenzie: MacKinnon 1, Jones 2
ISS: MacKinnon 1, Jones 2
The Hockey News: MacKinnon 1, Jones 2
Hockey Prospect: MacKinnon 1, Jones 2

Hockey Prospectus (Corey Pronman): Drouin 1, MacKinnon 2, Jones 3

There really was no consensus #1 that year. It was 50/50 between Jones and MacKinnon and then Drouin was a clear 3. Barkov and Nichushkin were 4/5 in most rankings in some order.

So, the worst judge of talent on that list is Craig Button? Shocking.