Quote:
Originally Posted by Bingo
Teams find 2-3 players every draft at best, and the rest don't turn out.
But the backlash on his selection was off for me.
The Flames as a drafting group wouldn't have selected a player that they felt had zero ceiling and was destined to be the equivalent of a replacement level 7-8 defenseman.
|
In all fairness, I doubt the Flames as a drafting group felt this way about guys like Keegan Kanzig and Jake Boltmann at the time either. Obviously they liked Phillips, otherwise they wouldn't have taken him — I don't think that was ever in doubt. I think what some folks had concerns about was whether the Flames were right to like him as much as they clearly do.
In the case of a guy like Boltmann (or Cam Whynot, or a couple others), it was never all that clear whatsoever why the Flames felt he was worth any pick at all, let alone a third rounder. I think it's fair for people to have the memory of that pick in the back of their mind when the same team picks a guy with a somewhat similar profile in the same round. Certainly not to take anything away from Phillips, though, he looked great in the two games.